Evaluating Roadside Perception for Autonomous Vehicles: Insights from Field Testing

Roadside perception systems are increasingly crucial in enhancing traffic safety and facilitating cooperative driving for autonomous vehicles. Despite rapid technological advancements, a major challenge persists for this newly arising field: the absence of standardized evaluation methods and benchmarks for these systems. This limitation hampers the ability to effectively assess and compare the performance of different systems, thus constraining progress in this vital field. This paper introduces a comprehensive evaluation methodology specifically designed to assess the performance of roadside perception systems. Our methodology encompasses measurement techniques, metric selection, and experimental trial design, all grounded in real-world field testing to ensure the practical applicability of our approach. We applied our methodology in Mcity\footnote{\url{https://mcity.umich.edu/}}, a controlled testing environment, to evaluate various off-the-shelf perception systems. This approach allowed for an in-depth comparative analysis of their performance in realistic scenarios, offering key insights into their respective strengths and limitations. The findings of this study are poised to inform the development of industry-standard benchmarks and evaluation methods, thereby enhancing the effectiveness of roadside perception system development and deployment for autonomous vehicles. We anticipate that this paper will stimulate essential discourse on standardizing evaluation methods for roadside perception systems, thus pushing the frontiers of this technology. Furthermore, our results offer both academia and industry a comprehensive understanding of the capabilities of contemporary infrastructure-based perception systems.

Evaluation of automated driving system safety metrics with logged vehicle trajectory data

Real-time safety metrics are important for the automated driving system (ADS) to assess the risk of driving situations and to assist the decision-making. Although a number of real-time safety metrics have been proposed in the literature, systematic performance evaluation of these safety metrics has been lacking. As different behavioral assumptions are adopted in different safety metrics, it is difficult to compare the safety metrics and evaluate their performance. To overcome this challenge, in this study, we propose an evaluation framework utilizing logged vehicle trajectory data, in that vehicle trajectories for both subject vehicle (SV) and background vehicles (BVs) are obtained and the prediction errors caused by behavioral assumptions can be eliminated. Specifically, we examine whether the SV is in a collision unavoidable situation at each moment, given all near-future trajectories of BVs. In this way, we level the ground for a fair comparison of different safety metrics, as a good safety metric should always alarm in advance to the collision unavoidable moment. When trajectory data from a large number of trips are available, we can systematically evaluate and compare different metrics' statistical performance. In the case study, three representative real-time safety metrics, including the time-to-collision (TTC), the PEGASUS Criticality Metric (PCM), and the Model Predictive Instantaneous Safety Metric (MPrISM), are evaluated using a large-scale simulated trajectory dataset. The proposed evaluation framework is important for researchers, practitioners, and regulators to characterize different metrics, and to select appropriate metrics for different applications. Moreover, by conducting failure analysis on moments when a safety metric failed, we can identify its potential weaknesses which are valuable for its potential refinements and improvements.

MSight: An Edge-Cloud Infrastructure-based Perception System for Connected Automated Vehicles

As vehicular communication and networking technologies continue to advance, infrastructure-based roadside perception emerges as a pivotal tool for connected automated vehicle (CAV) applications. Due to their elevated positioning, roadside sensors, including cameras and lidars, often enjoy unobstructed views with diminished object occlusion. This provides them a distinct advantage over onboard perception, enabling more robust and accurate detection of road objects. This paper presents MSight, a cutting-edge roadside perception system specifically designed for CAVs. MSight offers real-time vehicle detection, localization, tracking, and short-term trajectory prediction. Evaluations underscore the system's capability to uphold lane-level accuracy with minimal latency, revealing a range of potential applications to enhance CAV safety and efficiency. Presently, MSight operates 24/7 at a two-lane roundabout in the City of Ann Arbor, Michigan.

Robust Roadside Perception for Autonomous Driving: an Annotation-free Strategy with Synthesized Data

Recently, with the rapid development in vehicle-to-infrastructure communication technologies, the infrastructure-based, roadside perception system for cooperative driving has become a rising field. This paper focuses on one of the most critical challenges - the data-insufficiency problem. The lacking of high-quality labeled roadside sensor data with high diversity leads to low robustness, and low transfer-ability of current roadside perception systems. In this paper, a novel approach is proposed to address this problem by creating synthesized training data using Augmented Reality and Generative Adversarial Network. This method creates synthesized dataset that is capable of training or fine-tuning a roadside perception detector which is robust to different weather and lighting conditions, or to adapt a new deployment location. We validate our approach at two intersections: Mcity intersection and State St/Ellsworth Rd roundabout. Our experiments show that (1) the detector can achieve good performance in all conditions when trained on synthesized data only, and (2) the performance of an existing detector trained with labeled data can be enhanced by synthesized data in harsh conditions.

ROCO: A Roundabout Traffic Conflict Dataset

Traffic conflicts have been studied by the transportation research community as a surrogate safety measure for decades. However, due to the rarity of traffic conflicts, collecting large-scale real-world traffic conflict data becomes extremely challenging. In this paper, we introduce and analyze ROCO - a real-world roundabout traffic conflict dataset. The data is collected at a two-lane roundabout at the intersection of State St. and W. Ellsworth Rd. in Ann Arbor, Michigan. We use raw video dataflow captured from four fisheye cameras installed at the roundabout as our input data source. We adopt a learning-based conflict identification algorithm from video to find potential traffic conflicts, and then manually label them for dataset collection and annotation. In total 557 traffic conflicts and 17 traffic crashes are collected from August 2021 to October 2021. We provide trajectory data of the traffic conflict scenes extracted using our roadside perception system. Taxonomy based on traffic conflict severity, reason for the traffic conflict, and its effect on the traffic flow is provided. With the traffic conflict data collected, we discover that failure to yield to circulating vehicles when entering the roundabout is the largest contributing reason for traffic conflicts. ROCO dataset will be made public in the short future.

"Curse of rarity" for autonomous vehicles

Achieving the human-level safety performance for autonomous vehicles (AVs) remains a challenge. One critical bottleneck is the so-called "long-tail challenge", which usually refers to the problem that AVs should be able to handle seemingly endless low-probability safety-critical driving scenarios, even though millions of testing miles have been accumulated on public roads. However, there is neither rigorous definition nor analysis of properties of such problems, which hinders the progress of addressing them. In this paper, we systematically analyze the "long-tail challenge" and propose the concept of "curse of rarity" (CoR) for AVs. We conclude that the compounding effects of the CoR on top of the "curse of dimensionality" (CoD) are the root cause of the "long-tail challenge", because of the rarity of safety-critical events in high dimensionality of driving environments. We discuss the CoR in various aspects of AV development including perception, prediction, and planning, as well as validation and verification. Based on these analyses and discussions, we propose potential solutions to address the CoR in order to accelerate AV development and deployment.

Real-time Full-stack Traffic Scene Perception for Autonomous Driving with Roadside Cameras

We propose a novel and pragmatic framework for traffic scene perception with roadside cameras. The proposed framework covers a full-stack of roadside perception pipeline for infrastructure-assisted autonomous driving, including object detection, object localization, object tracking, and multi-camera information fusion. Unlike previous vision-based perception frameworks rely upon depth offset or 3D annotation at training, we adopt a modular decoupling design and introduce a landmark-based 3D localization method, where the detection and localization can be well decoupled so that the model can be easily trained based on only 2D annotations. The proposed framework applies to either optical or thermal cameras with pinhole or fish-eye lenses. Our framework is deployed at a two-lane roundabout located at Ellsworth Rd. and State St., Ann Arbor, MI, USA, providing 7x24 real-time traffic flow monitoring and high-precision vehicle trajectory extraction. The whole system runs efficiently on a low-power edge computing device with all-component end-to-end delay of less than 20ms.

A hierarchical behavior prediction framework at signalized intersections

Road user behavior prediction is one of the most critical components in trajectory planning for autonomous driving, especially in urban scenarios involving traffic signals. In this paper, a hierarchical framework is proposed to predict vehicle behaviors at a signalized intersection, using the traffic signal information of the intersection. The framework is composed of two phases: a discrete intention prediction phase and a continuous trajectory prediction phase. In the discrete intention prediction phase, a Bayesian network is adopted to predict the vehicle's high-level intention, after that, maximum entropy inverse reinforcement learning is utilized to learn the human driving model offline; during the online trajectory prediction phase, a driver characteristic is designed and updated to capture the different driving preferences between human drivers. We applied the proposed framework to one of the most challenging scenarios in autonomous driving: the yellow light running scenario. Numerical experiment results are presented in the later part of the paper which show the viability of the method. The accuracy of the Bayesian network for discrete intention prediction is 91.1%, and the prediction results are getting more and more accurate as the yellow time elapses. The average Euclidean distance error in continuous trajectory prediction is only 0.85 m in the yellow light running scenario.

A probabilistic model for missing traffic volume reconstruction based on data fusion

Traffic volume information is critical for intelligent transportation systems. It serves as a key input to transportation planning, roadway design, and traffic signal control. However, the traffic volume data collected by fixed-location sensors, such as loop detectors, often suffer from the missing data problem and low coverage problem. The missing data problem could be caused by hardware malfunction. The low coverage problem is due to the limited coverage of fixed-location sensors in the transportation network, which restrains our understanding of the traffic at the network level. To tackle these problems, we propose a probabilistic model for traffic volume reconstruction by fusing fixed-location sensor data and probe vehicle data. We apply the probabilistic principal component analysis (PPCA) to capture the correlations in traffic volume data. An innovative contribution of this work is that we also integrate probe vehicle data into the framework, which allows the model to solve both of the above-mentioned two problems. Using a real-world traffic volume dataset, we show that the proposed method outperforms state-of-the-art methods for the extensively studied missing data problem. Moreover, for the low coverage problem, which cannot be handled by most existing methods, the proposed model can also achieve high accuracy. The experiments also show that even when the missing ratio reaches 80%, the proposed method can still give an accurate estimate of the unknown traffic volumes with only a 10% probe vehicle penetration rate. The results validate the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed model and demonstrate its potential for practical applications.

Corner Case Generation and Analysis for Safety Assessment of Autonomous Vehicles

Testing and evaluation is a crucial step in the development and deployment of Connected and Automated Vehicles (CAVs). To comprehensively evaluate the performance of CAVs, it is of necessity to test the CAVs in safety-critical scenarios, which rarely happen in naturalistic driving environment. Therefore, how to purposely and systematically generate these corner cases becomes an important problem. Most existing studies focus on generating adversarial examples for perception systems of CAVs, whereas limited efforts have been put on the decision-making systems, which is the highlight of this paper. As the CAVs need to interact with numerous background vehicles (BVs) for a long duration, variables that define the corner cases are usually high dimensional, which makes the generation a challenging problem. In this paper, a unified framework is proposed to generate corner cases for the decision-making systems. To address the challenge brought by high dimensionality, the driving environment is formulated based on Markov Decision Process, and the deep reinforcement learning techniques are applied to learn the behavior policy of BVs. With the learned policy, BVs will behave and interact with the CAVs more aggressively, resulting in more corner cases. To further analyze the generated corner cases, the techniques of feature extraction and clustering are utilized. By selecting representative cases of each cluster and outliers, the valuable corner cases can be identified from all generated corner cases. Simulation results of a highway driving environment show that the proposed methods can effectively generate and identify the valuable corner cases.