Rethinking Processing Distortions: Disentangling the Impact of Speech Enhancement Errors on Speech Recognition Performance

It is challenging to improve automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance in noisy conditions with a single-channel speech enhancement (SE) front-end. This is generally attributed to the processing distortions caused by the nonlinear processing of single-channel SE front-ends. However, the causes of such degraded ASR performance have not been fully investigated. How to design single-channel SE front-ends in a way that significantly improves ASR performance remains an open research question. In this study, we investigate a signal-level numerical metric that can explain the cause of degradation in ASR performance. To this end, we propose a novel analysis scheme based on the orthogonal projection-based decomposition of SE errors. This scheme manually modifies the ratio of the decomposed interference, noise, and artifact errors, and it enables us to directly evaluate the impact of each error type on ASR performance. Our analysis reveals the particularly detrimental effect of artifact errors on ASR performance compared to the other types of errors. This provides us with a more principled definition of processing distortions that cause the ASR performance degradation. Then, we study two practical approaches for reducing the impact of artifact errors. First, we prove that the simple observation adding (OA) post-processing (i.e., interpolating the enhanced and observed signals) can monotonically improve the signal-to-artifact ratio. Second, we propose a novel training objective, called artifact-boosted signal-to-distortion ratio (AB-SDR), which forces the model to estimate the enhanced signals with fewer artifact errors. Through experiments, we confirm that both the OA and AB-SDR approaches are effective in decreasing artifact errors caused by single-channel SE front-ends, allowing them to significantly improve ASR performance.

Probing Self-supervised Learning Models with Target Speech Extraction

Large-scale pre-trained self-supervised learning (SSL) models have shown remarkable advancements in speech-related tasks. However, the utilization of these models in complex multi-talker scenarios, such as extracting a target speaker in a mixture, is yet to be fully evaluated. In this paper, we introduce target speech extraction (TSE) as a novel downstream task to evaluate the feature extraction capabilities of pre-trained SSL models. TSE uniquely requires both speaker identification and speech separation, distinguishing it from other tasks in the Speech processing Universal PERformance Benchmark (SUPERB) evaluation. Specifically, we propose a TSE downstream model composed of two lightweight task-oriented modules based on the same frozen SSL model. One module functions as a speaker encoder to obtain target speaker information from an enrollment speech, while the other estimates the target speaker's mask to extract its speech from the mixture. Experimental results on the Libri2mix datasets reveal the relevance of the TSE downstream task to probe SSL models, as its performance cannot be simply deduced from other related tasks such as speaker verification and separation.

Target Speech Extraction with Pre-trained Self-supervised Learning Models

Pre-trained self-supervised learning (SSL) models have achieved remarkable success in various speech tasks. However, their potential in target speech extraction (TSE) has not been fully exploited. TSE aims to extract the speech of a target speaker in a mixture guided by enrollment utterances. We exploit pre-trained SSL models for two purposes within a TSE framework, i.e., to process the input mixture and to derive speaker embeddings from the enrollment. In this paper, we focus on how to effectively use SSL models for TSE. We first introduce a novel TSE downstream task following the SUPERB principles. This simple experiment shows the potential of SSL models for TSE, but extraction performance remains far behind the state-of-the-art. We then extend a powerful TSE architecture by incorporating two SSL-based modules: an Adaptive Input Enhancer (AIE) and a speaker encoder. Specifically, the proposed AIE utilizes intermediate representations from the CNN encoder by adjusting the time resolution of CNN encoder and transformer blocks through progressive upsampling, capturing both fine-grained and hierarchical features. Our method outperforms current TSE systems achieving a SI-SDR improvement of 14.0 dB on LibriMix. Moreover, we can further improve performance by 0.7 dB by fine-tuning the whole model including the SSL model parameters.

Array Geometry-Robust Attention-Based Neural Beamformer for Moving Speakers

Recently, a mask-based beamformer with attention-based spatial covariance matrix aggregator (ASA) was proposed, which was demonstrated to track moving sources accurately. However, the deep neural network model used in this algorithm is limited to a specific channel configuration, requiring a different model in case a different channel permutation, channel count, or microphone array geometry is considered. Addressing this limitation, in this paper, we investigate three approaches to improve the robustness of the ASA-based tracking method against such variations: incorporating random channel configurations during the training process, employing the transform-average-concatenate (TAC) method to process multi-channel input features (allowing for any channel count and enabling permutation invariance), and utilizing input features that are robust against variations of the channel configuration. Our experiments, conducted using the CHiME-3 and DEMAND datasets, demonstrate improved robustness against mismatches in channel permutations, channel counts, and microphone array geometries compared to the conventional ASA-based tracking method without compromising performance in matched conditions, suggesting that the mask-based beamformer with ASA integrating the proposed approaches has the potential to track moving sources for arbitrary microphone arrays.

Lattice Rescoring Based on Large Ensemble of Complementary Neural Language Models

We investigate the effectiveness of using a large ensemble of advanced neural language models (NLMs) for lattice rescoring on automatic speech recognition (ASR) hypotheses. Previous studies have reported the effectiveness of combining a small number of NLMs. In contrast, in this study, we combine up to eight NLMs, i.e., forward/backward long short-term memory/Transformer-LMs that are trained with two different random initialization seeds. We combine these NLMs through iterative lattice generation. Since these NLMs work complementarily with each other, by combining them one by one at each rescoring iteration, language scores attached to given lattice arcs can be gradually refined. Consequently, errors of the ASR hypotheses can be gradually reduced. We also investigate the effectiveness of carrying over contextual information (previous rescoring results) across a lattice sequence of a long speech such as a lecture speech. In experiments using a lecture speech corpus, by combining the eight NLMs and using context carry-over, we obtained a 24.4% relative word error rate reduction from the ASR 1-best baseline. For further comparison, we performed simultaneous (i.e., non-iterative) NLM combination and 100-best rescoring using the large ensemble of NLMs, which confirmed the advantage of lattice rescoring with iterative NLM combination.

How does end-to-end speech recognition training impact speech enhancement artifacts?

Jointly training a speech enhancement (SE) front-end and an automatic speech recognition (ASR) back-end has been investigated as a way to mitigate the influence of \emph{processing distortion} generated by single-channel SE on ASR. In this paper, we investigate the effect of such joint training on the signal-level characteristics of the enhanced signals from the viewpoint of the decomposed noise and artifact errors. The experimental analyses provide two novel findings: 1) ASR-level training of the SE front-end reduces the artifact errors while increasing the noise errors, and 2) simply interpolating the enhanced and observed signals, which achieves a similar effect of reducing artifacts and increasing noise, improves ASR performance without jointly modifying the SE and ASR modules, even for a strong ASR back-end using a WavLM feature extractor. Our findings provide a better understanding of the effect of joint training and a novel insight for designing an ASR agnostic SE front-end.

Neural network-based virtual microphone estimation with virtual microphone and beamformer-level multi-task loss

Array processing performance depends on the number of microphones available. Virtual microphone estimation (VME) has been proposed to increase the number of microphone signals artificially. Neural network-based VME (NN-VME) trains an NN with a VM-level loss to predict a signal at a microphone location that is available during training but not at inference. However, this training objective may not be optimal for a specific array processing back-end, such as beamforming. An alternative approach is to use a training objective considering the array-processing back-end, such as a loss on the beamformer output. This approach may generate signals optimal for beamforming but not physically grounded. To combine the advantages of both approaches, this paper proposes a multi-task loss for NN-VME that combines both VM-level and beamformer-level losses. We evaluate the proposed multi-task NN-VME on multi-talker underdetermined conditions and show that it achieves a 33.1 % relative WER improvement compared to using only real microphones and 10.8 % compared to using a prior NN-VME approach.

Modified Parametric Multichannel Wiener Filter \\for Low-latency Enhancement of Speech Mixtures with Unknown Number of Speakers

This paper introduces a novel low-latency online beamforming (BF) algorithm, named Modified Parametric Multichannel Wiener Filter (Mod-PMWF), for enhancing speech mixtures with unknown and varying number of speakers. Although conventional BFs such as linearly constrained minimum variance BF (LCMV BF) can enhance a speech mixture, they typically require such attributes of the speech mixture as the number of speakers and the acoustic transfer functions (ATFs) from the speakers to the microphones. When the mixture attributes are unavailable, estimating them by low-latency processing is challenging, hindering the application of the BFs to the problem. In this paper, we overcome this problem by modifying a conventional Parametric Multichannel Wiener Filter (PMWF). The proposed Mod-PMWF can adaptively form a directivity pattern that enhances all the speakers in the mixture without explicitly estimating these attributes. Our experiments will show the proposed BF's effectiveness in interference reduction ratios and subjective listening tests.

Multi-Stream Extension of Variational Bayesian HMM Clustering (MS-VBx) for Combined End-to-End and Vector Clustering-based Diarization

Combining end-to-end neural speaker diarization (EEND) with vector clustering (VC), known as EEND-VC, has gained interest for leveraging the strengths of both methods. EEND-VC estimates activities and speaker embeddings for all speakers within an audio chunk and uses VC to associate these activities with speaker identities across different chunks. EEND-VC generates thus multiple streams of embeddings, one for each speaker in a chunk. We can cluster these embeddings using constrained agglomerative hierarchical clustering (cAHC), ensuring embeddings from the same chunk belong to different clusters. This paper introduces an alternative clustering approach, a multi-stream extension of the successful Bayesian HMM clustering of x-vectors (VBx), called MS-VBx. Experiments on three datasets demonstrate that MS-VBx outperforms cAHC in diarization and speaker counting performance.

ConceptBeam: Concept Driven Target Speech Extraction

We propose a novel framework for target speech extraction based on semantic information, called ConceptBeam. Target speech extraction means extracting the speech of a target speaker in a mixture. Typical approaches have been exploiting properties of audio signals, such as harmonic structure and direction of arrival. In contrast, ConceptBeam tackles the problem with semantic clues. Specifically, we extract the speech of speakers speaking about a concept, i.e., a topic of interest, using a concept specifier such as an image or speech. Solving this novel problem would open the door to innovative applications such as listening systems that focus on a particular topic discussed in a conversation. Unlike keywords, concepts are abstract notions, making it challenging to directly represent a target concept. In our scheme, a concept is encoded as a semantic embedding by mapping the concept specifier to a shared embedding space. This modality-independent space can be built by means of deep metric learning using paired data consisting of images and their spoken captions. We use it to bridge modality-dependent information, i.e., the speech segments in the mixture, and the specified, modality-independent concept. As a proof of our scheme, we performed experiments using a set of images associated with spoken captions. That is, we generated speech mixtures from these spoken captions and used the images or speech signals as the concept specifiers. We then extracted the target speech using the acoustic characteristics of the identified segments. We compare ConceptBeam with two methods: one based on keywords obtained from recognition systems and another based on sound source separation. We show that ConceptBeam clearly outperforms the baseline methods and effectively extracts speech based on the semantic representation.