BLSTM-Based Confidence Estimation for End-to-End Speech Recognition

Confidence estimation, in which we estimate the reliability of each recognized token (e.g., word, sub-word, and character) in automatic speech recognition (ASR) hypotheses and detect incorrectly recognized tokens, is an important function for developing ASR applications. In this study, we perform confidence estimation for end-to-end (E2E) ASR hypotheses. Recent E2E ASR systems show high performance (e.g., around 5% token error rates) for various ASR tasks. In such situations, confidence estimation becomes difficult since we need to detect infrequent incorrect tokens from mostly correct token sequences. To tackle this imbalanced dataset problem, we employ a bidirectional long short-term memory (BLSTM)-based model as a strong binary-class (correct/incorrect) sequence labeler that is trained with a class balancing objective. We experimentally confirmed that, by utilizing several types of ASR decoding scores as its auxiliary features, the model steadily shows high confidence estimation performance under highly imbalanced settings. We also confirmed that the BLSTM-based model outperforms Transformer-based confidence estimation models, which greatly underestimate incorrect tokens.

Lattice Rescoring Based on Large Ensemble of Complementary Neural Language Models

We investigate the effectiveness of using a large ensemble of advanced neural language models (NLMs) for lattice rescoring on automatic speech recognition (ASR) hypotheses. Previous studies have reported the effectiveness of combining a small number of NLMs. In contrast, in this study, we combine up to eight NLMs, i.e., forward/backward long short-term memory/Transformer-LMs that are trained with two different random initialization seeds. We combine these NLMs through iterative lattice generation. Since these NLMs work complementarily with each other, by combining them one by one at each rescoring iteration, language scores attached to given lattice arcs can be gradually refined. Consequently, errors of the ASR hypotheses can be gradually reduced. We also investigate the effectiveness of carrying over contextual information (previous rescoring results) across a lattice sequence of a long speech such as a lecture speech. In experiments using a lecture speech corpus, by combining the eight NLMs and using context carry-over, we obtained a 24.4% relative word error rate reduction from the ASR 1-best baseline. For further comparison, we performed simultaneous (i.e., non-iterative) NLM combination and 100-best rescoring using the large ensemble of NLMs, which confirmed the advantage of lattice rescoring with iterative NLM combination.

Iterative Shallow Fusion of Backward Language Model for End-to-End Speech Recognition

We propose a new shallow fusion (SF) method to exploit an external backward language model (BLM) for end-to-end automatic speech recognition (ASR). The BLM has complementary characteristics with a forward language model (FLM), and the effectiveness of their combination has been confirmed by rescoring ASR hypotheses as post-processing. In the proposed SF, we iteratively apply the BLM to partial ASR hypotheses in the backward direction (i.e., from the possible next token to the start symbol) during decoding, substituting the newly calculated BLM scores for the scores calculated at the last iteration. To enhance the effectiveness of this iterative SF (ISF), we train a partial sentence-aware BLM (PBLM) using reversed text data including partial sentences, considering the framework of ISF. In experiments using an attention-based encoder-decoder ASR system, we confirmed that ISF using the PBLM shows comparable performance with SF using the FLM. By performing ISF, early pruning of prospective hypotheses can be prevented during decoding, and we can obtain a performance improvement compared to applying the PBLM as post-processing. Finally, we confirmed that, by combining SF and ISF, further performance improvement can be obtained thanks to the complementarity of the FLM and PBLM.

Discriminative Training of VBx Diarization

Bayesian HMM clustering of x-vector sequences (VBx) has become a widely adopted diarization baseline model in publications and challenges. It uses an HMM to model speaker turns, a generatively trained probabilistic linear discriminant analysis (PLDA) for speaker distribution modeling, and Bayesian inference to estimate the assignment of x-vectors to speakers. This paper presents a new framework for updating the VBx parameters using discriminative training, which directly optimizes a predefined loss. We also propose a new loss that better correlates with the diarization error rate compared to binary cross-entropy $\unicode{x2013}$ the default choice for diarization end-to-end systems. Proof-of-concept results across three datasets (AMI, CALLHOME, and DIHARD II) demonstrate the method's capability of automatically finding hyperparameters, achieving comparable performance to those found by extensive grid search, which typically requires additional hyperparameter behavior knowledge. Moreover, we show that discriminative fine-tuning of PLDA can further improve the model's performance. We release the source code with this publication.

NTT speaker diarization system for CHiME-7: multi-domain, multi-microphone End-to-end and vector clustering diarization

This paper details our speaker diarization system designed for multi-domain, multi-microphone casual conversations. The proposed diarization pipeline uses weighted prediction error (WPE)-based dereverberation as a front end, then applies end-to-end neural diarization with vector clustering (EEND-VC) to each channel separately. It integrates the diarization result obtained from each channel using diarization output voting error reduction plus overlap (DOVER-LAP). To harness the knowledge from the target domain and results integrated across all channels, we apply self-supervised adaptation for each session by retraining the EEND-VC with pseudo-labels derived from DOVER-LAP. The proposed system was incorporated into NTT's submission for the distant automatic speech recognition task in the CHiME-7 challenge. Our system achieved 65 % and 62 % relative improvements on development and eval sets compared to the organizer-provided VC-based baseline diarization system, securing third place in diarization performance.

Multi-Stream Extension of Variational Bayesian HMM Clustering (MS-VBx) for Combined End-to-End and Vector Clustering-based Diarization

Combining end-to-end neural speaker diarization (EEND) with vector clustering (VC), known as EEND-VC, has gained interest for leveraging the strengths of both methods. EEND-VC estimates activities and speaker embeddings for all speakers within an audio chunk and uses VC to associate these activities with speaker identities across different chunks. EEND-VC generates thus multiple streams of embeddings, one for each speaker in a chunk. We can cluster these embeddings using constrained agglomerative hierarchical clustering (cAHC), ensuring embeddings from the same chunk belong to different clusters. This paper introduces an alternative clustering approach, a multi-stream extension of the successful Bayesian HMM clustering of x-vectors (VBx), called MS-VBx. Experiments on three datasets demonstrate that MS-VBx outperforms cAHC in diarization and speaker counting performance.

Advances in integration of end-to-end neural and clustering-based diarization for real conversational speech

Recently, we proposed a novel speaker diarization method called End-to-End-Neural-Diarization-vector clustering (EEND-vector clustering) that integrates clustering-based and end-to-end neural network-based diarization approaches into one framework. The proposed method combines advantages of both frameworks, i.e. high diarization performance and handling of overlapped speech based on EEND, and robust handling of long recordings with an arbitrary number of speakers based on clustering-based approaches. However, the method was only evaluated so far on simulated 2-speaker meeting-like data. This paper is to (1) report recent advances we made to this framework, including newly introduced robust constrained clustering algorithms, and (2) experimentally show that the method can now significantly outperform competitive diarization methods such as Encoder-Decoder Attractor (EDA)-EEND, on CALLHOME data which comprises real conversational speech data including overlapped speech and an arbitrary number of speakers. By further analyzing the experimental results, this paper also discusses pros and cons of the proposed method and reveals potential for further improvement.

Integrating end-to-end neural and clustering-based diarization: Getting the best of both worlds

Recent diarization technologies can be categorized into two approaches, i.e., clustering and end-to-end neural approaches, which have different pros and cons. The clustering-based approaches assign speaker labels to speech regions by clustering speaker embeddings such as x-vectors. While it can be seen as a current state-of-the-art approach that works for various challenging data with reasonable robustness and accuracy, it has a critical disadvantage that it cannot handle overlapped speech that is inevitable in natural conversational data. In contrast, the end-to-end neural diarization (EEND), which directly predicts diarization labels using a neural network, was devised to handle the overlapped speech. While the EEND, which can easily incorporate emerging deep-learning technologies, has started outperforming the x-vector clustering approach in some realistic database, it is difficult to make it work for `long' recordings (e.g., recordings longer than 10 minutes) because of, e.g., its huge memory consumption. Block-wise independent processing is also difficult because it poses an inter-block label permutation problem, i.e., an ambiguity of the speaker label assignments between blocks. In this paper, we propose a simple but effective hybrid diarization framework that works with overlapped speech and for long recordings containing an arbitrary number of speakers. It modifies the conventional EEND framework to simultaneously output global speaker embeddings so that speaker clustering can be performed across blocks to solve the permutation problem. With experiments based on simulated noisy reverberant 2-speaker meeting-like data, we show that the proposed framework works significantly better than the original EEND especially when the input data is long.

Improving speaker discrimination of target speech extraction with time-domain SpeakerBeam

Target speech extraction, which extracts a single target source in a mixture given clues about the target speaker, has attracted increasing attention. We have recently proposed SpeakerBeam, which exploits an adaptation utterance of the target speaker to extract his/her voice characteristics that are then used to guide a neural network towards extracting speech of that speaker. SpeakerBeam presents a practical alternative to speech separation as it enables tracking speech of a target speaker across utterances, and achieves promising speech extraction performance. However, it sometimes fails when speakers have similar voice characteristics, such as in same-gender mixtures, because it is difficult to discriminate the target speaker from the interfering speakers. In this paper, we investigate strategies for improving the speaker discrimination capability of SpeakerBeam. First, we propose a time-domain implementation of SpeakerBeam similar to that proposed for a time-domain audio separation network (TasNet), which has achieved state-of-the-art performance for speech separation. Besides, we investigate (1) the use of spatial features to better discriminate speakers when microphone array recordings are available, (2) adding an auxiliary speaker identification loss for helping to learn more discriminative voice characteristics. We show experimentally that these strategies greatly improve speech extraction performance, especially for same-gender mixtures, and outperform TasNet in terms of target speech extraction.