On the convergence of loss and uncertainty-based active learning algorithms

We study convergence rates of loss and uncertainty-based active learning algorithms under various assumptions. First, we provide a set of conditions under which a convergence rate guarantee holds, and use this for linear classifiers and linearly separable datasets to show convergence rate guarantees for loss-based sampling and different loss functions. Second, we provide a framework that allows us to derive convergence rate bounds for loss-based sampling by deploying known convergence rate bounds for stochastic gradient descent algorithms. Third, and last, we propose an active learning algorithm that combines sampling of points and stochastic Polyak's step size. We show a condition on the sampling that ensures a convergence rate guarantee for this algorithm for smooth convex loss functions. Our numerical results demonstrate efficiency of our proposed algorithm.

Active learning with biased non-response to label requests

Active learning can improve the efficiency of training prediction models by identifying the most informative new labels to acquire. However, non-response to label requests can impact active learning's effectiveness in real-world contexts. We conceptualise this degradation by considering the type of non-response present in the data, demonstrating that biased non-response is particularly detrimental to model performance. We argue that this sort of non-response is particularly likely in contexts where the labelling process, by nature, relies on user interactions. To mitigate the impact of biased non-response, we propose a cost-based correction to the sampling strategy--the Upper Confidence Bound of the Expected Utility (UCB-EU)--that can, plausibly, be applied to any active learning algorithm. Through experiments, we demonstrate that our method successfully reduces the harm from labelling non-response in many settings. However, we also characterise settings where the non-response bias in the annotations remains detrimental under UCB-EU for particular sampling methods and data generating processes. Finally, we evaluate our method on a real-world dataset from e-commerce platform Taobao. We show that UCB-EU yields substantial performance improvements to conversion models that are trained on clicked impressions. Most generally, this research serves to both better conceptualise the interplay between types of non-response and model improvements via active learning, and to provide a practical, easy to implement correction that helps mitigate model degradation.

TCE: A Test-Based Approach to Measuring Calibration Error

This paper proposes a new metric to measure the calibration error of probabilistic binary classifiers, called test-based calibration error (TCE). TCE incorporates a novel loss function based on a statistical test to examine the extent to which model predictions differ from probabilities estimated from data. It offers (i) a clear interpretation, (ii) a consistent scale that is unaffected by class imbalance, and (iii) an enhanced visual representation with repect to the standard reliability diagram. In addition, we introduce an optimality criterion for the binning procedure of calibration error metrics based on a minimal estimation error of the empirical probabilities. We provide a novel computational algorithm for optimal bins under bin-size constraints. We demonstrate properties of TCE through a range of experiments, including multiple real-world imbalanced datasets and ImageNet 1000.

Explaining Predictive Uncertainty with Information Theoretic Shapley Values

Researchers in explainable artificial intelligence have developed numerous methods for helping users understand the predictions of complex supervised learning models. By contrast, explaining the $\textit{uncertainty}$ of model outputs has received relatively little attention. We adapt the popular Shapley value framework to explain various types of predictive uncertainty, quantifying each feature's contribution to the conditional entropy of individual model outputs. We consider games with modified characteristic functions and find deep connections between the resulting Shapley values and fundamental quantities from information theory and conditional independence testing. We outline inference procedures for finite sample error rate control with provable guarantees, and implement an efficient algorithm that performs well in a range of experiments on real and simulated data. Our method has applications to covariate shift detection, active learning, feature selection, and active feature-value acquisition.

Machine Learning for Fraud Detection in E-Commerce: A Research Agenda

Fraud detection and prevention play an important part in ensuring the sustained operation of any e-commerce business. Machine learning (ML) often plays an important role in these anti-fraud operations, but the organizational context in which these ML models operate cannot be ignored. In this paper, we take an organization-centric view on the topic of fraud detection by formulating an operational model of the anti-fraud departments in e-commerce organizations. We derive 6 research topics and 12 practical challenges for fraud detection from this operational model. We summarize the state of the literature for each research topic, discuss potential solutions to the practical challenges, and identify 22 open research challenges.

Mining Insights from Weakly-Structured Event Data

This thesis focuses on process mining on event data where such a normative specification is absent and, as a result, the event data is less structured. The thesis puts special emphasis on one application domain that fits this description: the analysis of smart home data where sequences of daily activities are recorded. In this thesis we propose a set of techniques to analyze such data, which can be grouped into two categories of techniques. The first category of methods focuses on preprocessing event logs in order to enable process discovery techniques to extract insights into unstructured event data. In this category we have developed the following techniques: - An unsupervised approach to refine event labels based on the time at which the event took place, allowing for example to distinguish recorded eating events into breakfast, lunch, and dinner. - An approach to detect and filter from event logs so-called chaotic activities, which are activities that cause process discovery methods to overgeneralize. - A supervised approach to abstract low-level events into more high-level events, where we show that there exist situations where process discovery approaches overgeneralize on the low-level event data but are able to find precise models on the high-level event data. The second category focuses on mining local process models, i.e., collections of process model patterns that each describe some frequent pattern, in contrast to the single global process model that is obtained with existing process discovery techniques. Several techniques are introduced in the area of local process model mining, including a basic method, fast but approximate heuristic methods, and constraint-based techniques.

Evaluating Conformance Measures in Process Mining using Conformance Propositions (Extended version)

Process mining sheds new light on the relationship between process models and real-life processes. Process discovery can be used to learn process models from event logs. Conformance checking is concerned with quantifying the quality of a business process model in relation to event data that was logged during the execution of the business process. There exist different categories of conformance measures. Recall, also called fitness, is concerned with quantifying how much of the behavior that was observed in the event log fits the process model. Precision is concerned with quantifying how much behavior a process model allows for that was never observed in the event log. Generalization is concerned with quantifying how well a process model generalizes to behavior that is possible in the business process but was never observed in the event log. Many recall, precision, and generalization measures have been developed throughout the years, but they are often defined in an ad-hoc manner without formally defining the desired properties up front. To address these problems, we formulate 21 conformance propositions and we use these propositions to evaluate current and existing conformance measures. The goal is to trigger a discussion by clearly formulating the challenges and requirements (rather than proposing new measures). Additionally, this paper serves as an overview of the conformance checking measures that are available in the process mining area.

Fire Now, Fire Later: Alarm-Based Systems for Prescriptive Process Monitoring

Predictive process monitoring is a family of techniques to analyze events produced during the execution of a business process in order to predict the future state or the final outcome of running process instances. Existing techniques in this field are able to predict, at each step of a process instance, the likelihood that it will lead to an undesired outcome.These techniques, however, focus on generating predictions and do not prescribe when and how process workers should intervene to decrease the cost of undesired outcomes. This paper proposes a framework for prescriptive process monitoring, which extends predictive monitoring with the ability to generate alarms that trigger interventions to prevent an undesired outcome or mitigate its effect. The framework incorporates a parameterized cost model to assess the cost-benefit trade-off of generating alarms. We show how to optimize the generation of alarms given an event log of past process executions and a set of cost model parameters. The proposed approaches are empirically evaluated using a range of real-life event logs. The experimental results show that the net cost of undesired outcomes can be minimized by changing the threshold for generating alarms, as the process instance progresses. Moreover, introducing delays for triggering alarms, instead of triggering them as soon as the probability of an undesired outcome exceeds a threshold, leads to lower net costs.

An Interdisciplinary Comparison of Sequence Modeling Methods for Next-Element Prediction

Data of sequential nature arise in many application domains in forms of, e.g. textual data, DNA sequences, and software execution traces. Different research disciplines have developed methods to learn sequence models from such datasets: (i) in the machine learning field methods such as (hidden) Markov models and recurrent neural networks have been developed and successfully applied to a wide-range of tasks, (ii) in process mining process discovery techniques aim to generate human-interpretable descriptive models, and (iii) in the grammar inference field the focus is on finding descriptive models in the form of formal grammars. Despite their different focuses, these fields share a common goal - learning a model that accurately describes the behavior in the underlying data. Those sequence models are generative, i.e, they can predict what elements are likely to occur after a given unfinished sequence. So far, these fields have developed mainly in isolation from each other and no comparison exists. This paper presents an interdisciplinary experimental evaluation that compares sequence modeling techniques on the task of next-element prediction on four real-life sequence datasets. The results indicate that machine learning techniques that generally have no aim at interpretability in terms of accuracy outperform techniques from the process mining and grammar inference fields that aim to yield interpretable models.

Mining Non-Redundant Local Process Models From Sequence Databases

Sequential pattern mining techniques extract patterns corresponding to frequent subsequences from a sequence database. A practical limitation of these techniques is that they overload the user with too many patterns. Local Process Model (LPM) mining is an alternative approach coming from the field of process mining. While in traditional sequential pattern mining, a pattern describes one subsequence, an LPM captures a set of subsequences. Also, while traditional sequential patterns only match subsequences that are observed in the sequence database, an LPM may capture subsequences that are not explicitly observed, but that are related to observed subsequences. In other words, LPMs generalize the behavior observed in the sequence database. These properties make it possible for a set of LPMs to cover the behavior of a much larger set of sequential patterns. Yet, existing LPM mining techniques still suffer from the pattern explosion problem because they produce sets of redundant LPMs. In this paper, we propose several heuristics to mine a set of non-redundant LPMs either from a set of redundant LPMs or from a set of sequential patterns. We empirically compare the proposed heuristics between them and against existing (local) process mining techniques in terms of coverage, redundancy, and complexity of the produced sets of LPMs.