Towards Evaluating Transfer-based Attacks Systematically, Practically, and Fairly

The adversarial vulnerability of deep neural networks (DNNs) has drawn great attention due to the security risk of applying these models in real-world applications. Based on transferability of adversarial examples, an increasing number of transfer-based methods have been developed to fool black-box DNN models whose architecture and parameters are inaccessible. Although tremendous effort has been exerted, there still lacks a standardized benchmark that could be taken advantage of to compare these methods systematically, fairly, and practically. Our investigation shows that the evaluation of some methods needs to be more reasonable and more thorough to verify their effectiveness, to avoid, for example, unfair comparison and insufficient consideration of possible substitute/victim models. Therefore, we establish a transfer-based attack benchmark (TA-Bench) which implements 30+ methods. In this paper, we evaluate and compare them comprehensively on 25 popular substitute/victim models on ImageNet. New insights about the effectiveness of these methods are gained and guidelines for future evaluations are provided. Code at: https://github.com/qizhangli/TA-Bench.

DualAug: Exploiting Additional Heavy Augmentation with OOD Data Rejection

Data augmentation is a dominant method for reducing model overfitting and improving generalization. Most existing data augmentation methods tend to find a compromise in augmenting the data, \textit{i.e.}, increasing the amplitude of augmentation carefully to avoid degrading some data too much and doing harm to the model performance. We delve into the relationship between data augmentation and model performance, revealing that the performance drop with heavy augmentation comes from the presence of out-of-distribution (OOD) data. Nonetheless, as the same data transformation has different effects for different training samples, even for heavy augmentation, there remains part of in-distribution data which is beneficial to model training. Based on the observation, we propose a novel data augmentation method, named \textbf{DualAug}, to keep the augmentation in distribution as much as possible at a reasonable time and computational cost. We design a data mixing strategy to fuse augmented data from both the basic- and the heavy-augmentation branches. Extensive experiments on supervised image classification benchmarks show that DualAug improve various automated data augmentation method. Moreover, the experiments on semi-supervised learning and contrastive self-supervised learning demonstrate that our DualAug can also improve related method. Code is available at \href{https://github.com/shuguang99/DualAug}{https://github.com/shuguang99/DualAug}.

Improving Transferability of Adversarial Examples via Bayesian Attacks

This paper presents a substantial extension of our work published at ICLR. Our ICLR work advocated for enhancing transferability in adversarial examples by incorporating a Bayesian formulation into model parameters, which effectively emulates the ensemble of infinitely many deep neural networks, while, in this paper, we introduce a novel extension by incorporating the Bayesian formulation into the model input as well, enabling the joint diversification of both the model input and model parameters. Our empirical findings demonstrate that: 1) the combination of Bayesian formulations for both the model input and model parameters yields significant improvements in transferability; 2) by introducing advanced approximations of the posterior distribution over the model input, adversarial transferability achieves further enhancement, surpassing all state-of-the-arts when attacking without model fine-tuning. Moreover, we propose a principled approach to fine-tune model parameters in such an extended Bayesian formulation. The derived optimization objective inherently encourages flat minima in the parameter space and input space. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method achieves a new state-of-the-art on transfer-based attacks, improving the average success rate on ImageNet and CIFAR-10 by 19.14% and 2.08%, respectively, when comparing with our ICLR basic Bayesian method. We will make our code publicly available.

Improving Adversarial Transferability via Intermediate-level Perturbation Decay

Intermediate-level attacks that attempt to perturb feature representations following an adversarial direction drastically have shown favorable performance in crafting transferable adversarial examples. Existing methods in this category are normally formulated with two separate stages, where a directional guide is required to be determined at first and the scalar projection of the intermediate-level perturbation onto the directional guide is enlarged thereafter. The obtained perturbation deviates from the guide inevitably in the feature space, and it is revealed in this paper that such a deviation may lead to sub-optimal attack. To address this issue, we develop a novel intermediate-level method that crafts adversarial examples within a single stage of optimization. In particular, the proposed method, named intermediate-level perturbation decay (ILPD), encourages the intermediate-level perturbation to be in an effective adversarial direction and to possess a great magnitude simultaneously. In-depth discussion verifies the effectiveness of our method. Experimental results show that it outperforms state-of-the-arts by large margins in attacking various victim models on ImageNet (+10.07% on average) and CIFAR-10 (+3.88% on average). Our code is at https://github.com/qizhangli/ILPD-attack.

Improving Adversarial Transferability by Intermediate-level Perturbation Decay

Intermediate-level attacks that attempt to perturb feature representations following an adversarial direction drastically have shown favorable performance in crafting transferable adversarial examples. Existing methods in this category are normally formulated with two separate stages, where a directional guide is required to be determined at first and the scalar projection of the intermediate-level perturbation onto the directional guide is enlarged thereafter. The obtained perturbation deviates from the guide inevitably in the feature space, and it is revealed in this paper that such a deviation may lead to sub-optimal attack. To address this issue, we develop a novel intermediate-level method that crafts adversarial examples within a single stage of optimization. In particular, the proposed method, named intermediate-level perturbation decay (ILPD), encourages the intermediate-level perturbation to be in an effective adversarial direction and to possess a great magnitude simultaneously. In-depth discussion verifies the effectiveness of our method. Experimental results show that it outperforms state-of-the-arts by large margins in attacking various victim models on ImageNet (+10.07% on average) and CIFAR-10 (+3.88% on average). Our code is at https://github.com/qizhangli/ILPD-attack.

Making Substitute Models More Bayesian Can Enhance Transferability of Adversarial Examples

The transferability of adversarial examples across deep neural networks (DNNs) is the crux of many black-box attacks. Many prior efforts have been devoted to improving the transferability via increasing the diversity in inputs of some substitute models. In this paper, by contrast, we opt for the diversity in substitute models and advocate to attack a Bayesian model for achieving desirable transferability. Deriving from the Bayesian formulation, we develop a principled strategy for possible finetuning, which can be combined with many off-the-shelf Gaussian posterior approximations over DNN parameters. Extensive experiments have been conducted to verify the effectiveness of our method, on common benchmark datasets, and the results demonstrate that our method outperforms recent state-of-the-arts by large margins (roughly 19% absolute increase in average attack success rate on ImageNet), and, by combining with these recent methods, further performance gain can be obtained. Our code: https://github.com/qizhangli/MoreBayesian-attack.

Adversarial Contrastive Learning via Asymmetric InfoNCE

Contrastive learning (CL) has recently been applied to adversarial learning tasks. Such practice considers adversarial samples as additional positive views of an instance, and by maximizing their agreements with each other, yields better adversarial robustness. However, this mechanism can be potentially flawed, since adversarial perturbations may cause instance-level identity confusion, which can impede CL performance by pulling together different instances with separate identities. To address this issue, we propose to treat adversarial samples unequally when contrasted, with an asymmetric InfoNCE objective ($A-InfoNCE$) that allows discriminating considerations of adversarial samples. Specifically, adversaries are viewed as inferior positives that induce weaker learning signals, or as hard negatives exhibiting higher contrast to other negative samples. In the asymmetric fashion, the adverse impacts of conflicting objectives between CL and adversarial learning can be effectively mitigated. Experiments show that our approach consistently outperforms existing Adversarial CL methods across different finetuning schemes without additional computational cost. The proposed A-InfoNCE is also a generic form that can be readily extended to other CL methods. Code is available at https://github.com/yqy2001/A-InfoNCE.

Collaborative Adversarial Training

The vulnerability of deep neural networks (DNNs) to adversarial examples has attracted great attention in the machine learning community. The problem is related to local non-smoothness and steepness of normally obtained loss landscapes. Training augmented with adversarial examples (a.k.a., adversarial training) is considered as an effective remedy. In this paper, we highlight that some collaborative examples, nearly perceptually indistinguishable from both adversarial and benign examples yet show extremely lower prediction loss, can be utilized to enhance adversarial training. A novel method called collaborative adversarial training (CoAT) is thus proposed to achieve new state-of-the-arts.

An Intermediate-level Attack Framework on The Basis of Linear Regression

This paper substantially extends our work published at ECCV, in which an intermediate-level attack was proposed to improve the transferability of some baseline adversarial examples. We advocate to establish a direct linear mapping from the intermediate-level discrepancies (between adversarial features and benign features) to classification prediction loss of the adversarial example. In this paper, we delve deep into the core components of such a framework by performing comprehensive studies and extensive experiments. We show that 1) a variety of linear regression models can all be considered in order to establish the mapping, 2) the magnitude of the finally obtained intermediate-level discrepancy is linearly correlated with adversarial transferability, 3) further boost of the performance can be achieved by performing multiple runs of the baseline attack with random initialization. By leveraging these findings, we achieve new state-of-the-arts on transfer-based $\ell_\infty$ and $\ell_2$ attacks.