Bridging the Gap: A Survey on Integrating Feedback for Natural Language Generation

Many recent advances in natural language generation have been fueled by training large language models on internet-scale data. However, this paradigm can lead to models that generate toxic, inaccurate, and unhelpful content, and automatic evaluation metrics often fail to identify these behaviors. As models become more capable, human feedback is an invaluable signal for evaluating and improving models. This survey aims to provide an overview of the recent research that has leveraged human feedback to improve natural language generation. First, we introduce an encompassing formalization of feedback, and identify and organize existing research into a taxonomy following this formalization. Next, we discuss how feedback can be described by its format and objective, and cover the two approaches proposed to use feedback (either for training or decoding): directly using the feedback or training feedback models. We also discuss existing datasets for human-feedback data collection, and concerns surrounding feedback collection. Finally, we provide an overview of the nascent field of AI feedback, which exploits large language models to make judgments based on a set of principles and minimize the need for human intervention.

Chunk-based Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation

Semi-parametric models, which augment generation with retrieval, have led to impressive results in language modeling and machine translation, due to their ability to leverage information retrieved from a datastore of examples. One of the most prominent approaches, $k$NN-MT, has an outstanding performance on domain adaptation by retrieving tokens from a domain-specific datastore \citep{khandelwal2020nearest}. However, $k$NN-MT requires retrieval for every single generated token, leading to a very low decoding speed (around 8 times slower than a parametric model). In this paper, we introduce a \textit{chunk-based} $k$NN-MT model which retrieves chunks of tokens from the datastore, instead of a single token. We propose several strategies for incorporating the retrieved chunks into the generation process, and for selecting the steps at which the model needs to search for neighbors in the datastore. Experiments on machine translation in two settings, static domain adaptation and ``on-the-fly'' adaptation, show that the chunk-based $k$NN-MT model leads to a significant speed-up (up to 4 times) with only a small drop in translation quality.

Efficient Machine Translation Domain Adaptation

Machine translation models struggle when translating out-of-domain text, which makes domain adaptation a topic of critical importance. However, most domain adaptation methods focus on fine-tuning or training the entire or part of the model on every new domain, which can be costly. On the other hand, semi-parametric models have been shown to successfully perform domain adaptation by retrieving examples from an in-domain datastore (Khandelwal et al., 2021). A drawback of these retrieval-augmented models, however, is that they tend to be substantially slower. In this paper, we explore several approaches to speed up nearest neighbor machine translation. We adapt the methods recently proposed by He et al. (2021) for language modeling, and introduce a simple but effective caching strategy that avoids performing retrieval when similar contexts have been seen before. Translation quality and runtimes for several domains show the effectiveness of the proposed solutions.

$\infty$-former: Infinite Memory Transformer

Transformers struggle when attending to long contexts, since the amount of computation grows with the context length, and therefore they cannot model long-term memories effectively. Several variations have been proposed to alleviate this problem, but they all have a finite memory capacity, being forced to drop old information. In this paper, we propose the $\infty$-former, which extends the vanilla transformer with an unbounded long-term memory. By making use of a continuous-space attention mechanism to attend over the long-term memory, the $\infty$-former's attention complexity becomes independent of the context length. Thus, it is able to model arbitrarily long contexts and maintain "sticky memories" while keeping a fixed computation budget. Experiments on a synthetic sorting task demonstrate the ability of the $\infty$-former to retain information from long sequences. We also perform experiments on language modeling, by training a model from scratch and by fine-tuning a pre-trained language model, which show benefits of unbounded long-term memories.

The GEM Benchmark: Natural Language Generation, its Evaluation and Metrics

We introduce GEM, a living benchmark for natural language Generation (NLG), its Evaluation, and Metrics. Measuring progress in NLG relies on a constantly evolving ecosystem of automated metrics, datasets, and human evaluation standards. However, due to this moving target, new models often still evaluate on divergent anglo-centric corpora with well-established, but flawed, metrics. This disconnect makes it challenging to identify the limitations of current models and opportunities for progress. Addressing this limitation, GEM provides an environment in which models can easily be applied to a wide set of corpora and evaluation strategies can be tested. Regular updates to the benchmark will help NLG research become more multilingual and evolve the challenge alongside models. This paper serves as the description of the initial release for which we are organizing a shared task at our ACL 2021 Workshop and to which we invite the entire NLG community to participate.

Sparse Text Generation

Current state-of-the-art text generators build on powerful language models such as GPT-2, which have impressive performance. However, to avoid degenerate text, they require sampling from a modified softmax, via temperature parameters or ad-hoc truncation techniques, as in top-$k$ or nucleus sampling. This creates a mismatch between training and testing conditions. In this paper, we use the recently introduced entmax transformation to train and sample from a natively sparse language model, avoiding this mismatch. The result is a text generator with favorable performance in terms of fluency and consistency, fewer repetitions, and n-gram diversity closer to human text. In order to evaluate our model, we propose three new metrics that are tailored for comparing sparse or truncated distributions: $\epsilon$-perplexity, sparsemax score, and Jensen-Shannon divergence. Human-evaluated experiments in story completion and dialogue generation show that entmax sampling leads to more engaging and coherent stories and conversations.

Sparse and Structured Visual Attention

Visual attention mechanisms are widely used in multimodal tasks, such as image captioning and visual question answering (VQA). One drawback of softmax-based attention mechanisms is that they assign probability mass to all image regions, regardless of their adjacency structure and of their relevance to the text. In this paper, to better link the image structure with the text, we replace the traditional softmax attention mechanism with two alternative sparsity-promoting transformations: sparsemax, which is able to select the relevant regions only (assigning zero weight to the rest), and a newly proposed Total-Variation Sparse Attention (TVmax), which further encourages the joint selection of adjacent spatial locations. Experiments in image captioning and VQA, using both LSTM and Transformer architectures, show gains in terms of human-rated caption quality, attention relevance, and VQA accuracy, with improved interpretability.

Joint Learning of Named Entity Recognition and Entity Linking

Named entity recognition (NER) and entity linking (EL) are two fundamentally related tasks, since in order to perform EL, first the mentions to entities have to be detected. However, most entity linking approaches disregard the mention detection part, assuming that the correct mentions have been previously detected. In this paper, we perform joint learning of NER and EL to leverage their relatedness and obtain a more robust and generalisable system. For that, we introduce a model inspired by the Stack-LSTM approach (Dyer et al., 2015). We observe that, in fact, doing multi-task learning of NER and EL improves the performance in both tasks when comparing with models trained with individual objectives. Furthermore, we achieve results competitive with the state-of-the-art in both NER and EL.

A deep learning approach for understanding natural language commands for mobile service robots

Using natural language to give instructions to robots is challenging, since natural language understanding is still largely an open problem. In this paper we address this problem by restricting our attention to commands modeled as one action, plus arguments (also known as slots). For action detection (also called intent detection) and slot filling various architectures of Recurrent Neural Networks and Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) networks were evaluated, having LSTMs achieved a superior accuracy. As the action requested may not fall within the robots capabilities, a Support Vector Machine(SVM) is used to determine whether it is or not. For the input of the neural networks, several word embedding algorithms were compared. Finally, to implement the system in a robot, a ROS package is created using a SMACH state machine. The proposed system is then evaluated both using well-known datasets and benchmarks in the context of domestic service robots.