NeurIPS 2022 Competition: Driving SMARTS

Driving SMARTS is a regular competition designed to tackle problems caused by the distribution shift in dynamic interaction contexts that are prevalent in real-world autonomous driving (AD). The proposed competition supports methodologically diverse solutions, such as reinforcement learning (RL) and offline learning methods, trained on a combination of naturalistic AD data and open-source simulation platform SMARTS. The two-track structure allows focusing on different aspects of the distribution shift. Track 1 is open to any method and will give ML researchers with different backgrounds an opportunity to solve a real-world autonomous driving challenge. Track 2 is designed for strictly offline learning methods. Therefore, direct comparisons can be made between different methods with the aim to identify new promising research directions. The proposed setup consists of 1) realistic traffic generated using real-world data and micro simulators to ensure fidelity of the scenarios, 2) framework accommodating diverse methods for solving the problem, and 3) baseline method. As such it provides a unique opportunity for the principled investigation into various aspects of autonomous vehicle deployment.

Benchmarking Constraint Inference in Inverse Reinforcement Learning

When deploying Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents into a physical system, we must ensure that these agents are well aware of the underlying constraints. In many real-world problems, however, the constraints followed by expert agents (e.g., humans) are often hard to specify mathematically and unknown to the RL agents. To tackle these issues, Constraint Inverse Reinforcement Learning (CIRL) considers the formalism of Constrained Markov Decision Processes (CMDPs) and estimates constraints from expert demonstrations by learning a constraint function. As an emerging research topic, CIRL does not have common benchmarks, and previous works tested their algorithms with hand-crafted environments (e.g., grid worlds). In this paper, we construct a CIRL benchmark in the context of two major application domains: robot control and autonomous driving. We design relevant constraints for each environment and empirically study the ability of different algorithms to recover those constraints based on expert trajectories that respect those constraints. To handle stochastic dynamics, we propose a variational approach that infers constraint distributions, and we demonstrate its performance by comparing it with other CIRL baselines on our benchmark. The benchmark, including the information for reproducing the performance of CIRL algorithms, is publicly available at https://github.com/Guiliang/CIRL-benchmarks-public

Learning Soft Constraints From Constrained Expert Demonstrations

Inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) methods assume that the expert data is generated by an agent optimizing some reward function. However, in many settings, the agent may optimize a reward function subject to some constraints, where the constraints induce behaviors that may be otherwise difficult to express with just a reward function. We consider the setting where the reward function is given, and the constraints are unknown, and propose a method that is able to recover these constraints satisfactorily from the expert data. While previous work has focused on recovering hard constraints, our method can recover cumulative soft constraints that the agent satisfies on average per episode. In IRL fashion, our method solves this problem by adjusting the constraint function iteratively through a constrained optimization procedure, until the agent behavior matches the expert behavior. Despite the simplicity of the formulation, our method is able to obtain good results. We demonstrate our approach on synthetic environments and real world highway driving data.

Multi-lane Cruising Using Hierarchical Planning and Reinforcement Learning

Competent multi-lane cruising requires using lane changes and within-lane maneuvers to achieve good speed and maintain safety. This paper proposes a design for autonomous multi-lane cruising by combining a hierarchical reinforcement learning framework with a novel state-action space abstraction. While the proposed solution follows the classical hierarchy of behavior decision, motion planning and control, it introduces a key intermediate abstraction within the motion planner to discretize the state-action space according to high level behavioral decisions. We argue that this design allows principled modular extension of motion planning, in contrast to using either monolithic behavior cloning or a large set of hand-written rules. Moreover, we demonstrate that our state-action space abstraction allows transferring of the trained models without retraining from a simulated environment with virtually no dynamics to one with significantly more realistic dynamics. Together, these results suggest that our proposed hierarchical architecture is a promising way to allow reinforcement learning to be applied to complex multi-lane cruising in the real world.

How To Not Drive: Learning Driving Constraints from Demonstration

We propose a new scheme to learn motion planning constraints from human driving trajectories. Behavioral and motion planning are the key components in an autonomous driving system. The behavioral planning is responsible for high-level decision making required to follow traffic rules and interact with other road participants. The motion planner role is to generate feasible, safe trajectories for a self-driving vehicle to follow. The trajectories are generated through an optimization scheme to optimize a cost function based on metrics related to smoothness, movability, and comfort, and subject to a set of constraints derived from the planned behavior, safety considerations, and feasibility. A common practice is to manually design the cost function and constraints. Recent work has investigated learning the cost function from human driving demonstrations. While effective, the practical application of such approaches is still questionable in autonomous driving. In contrast, this paper focuses on learning driving constraints, which can be used as an add-on module to existing autonomous driving solutions. To learn the constraint, the planning problem is formulated as a constrained Markov Decision Process, whose elements are assumed to be known except the constraints. The constraints are then learned by learning the distribution of expert trajectories and estimating the probability of optimal trajectories belonging to the learned distribution. The proposed scheme is evaluated using NGSIM dataset, yielding less than 1\% collision rate and out of road maneuvers when the learned constraints is used in an optimization-based motion planner.

Motion Planning for Autonomous Vehicles in the Presence of Uncertainty Using Reinforcement Learning

Motion planning under uncertainty is one of the main challenges in developing autonomous driving vehicles. In this work, we focus on the uncertainty in sensing and perception, resulted from a limited field of view, occlusions, and sensing range. This problem is often tackled by considering hypothetical hidden objects in occluded areas or beyond the sensing range to guarantee passive safety. However, this may result in conservative planning and expensive computation, particularly when numerous hypothetical objects need to be considered. We propose a reinforcement learning (RL) based solution to manage uncertainty by optimizing for the worst case outcome. This approach is in contrast to traditional RL, where the agents try to maximize the average expected reward. The proposed approach is built on top of the Distributional RL with its policy optimization maximizing the stochastic outcomes' lower bound. This modification can be applied to a range of RL algorithms. As a proof-of-concept, the approach is applied to two different RL algorithms, Soft Actor-Critic and DQN. The approach is evaluated against two challenging scenarios of pedestrians crossing with occlusion and curved roads with a limited field of view. The algorithm is trained and evaluated using the SUMO traffic simulator. The proposed approach yields much better motion planning behavior compared to conventional RL algorithms and behaves comparably to humans driving style.

CoachNet: An Adversarial Sampling Approach for Reinforcement Learning

Despite the recent successes of reinforcement learning in games and robotics, it is yet to become broadly practical. Sample efficiency and unreliable performance in rare but challenging scenarios are two of the major obstacles. Drawing inspiration from the effectiveness of deliberate practice for achieving expert-level human performance, we propose a new adversarial sampling approach guided by a failure predictor named "CoachNet". CoachNet is trained online along with the agent to predict the probability of failure. This probability is then used in a stochastic sampling process to guide the agent to more challenging episodes. This way, instead of wasting time on scenarios that the agent has already mastered, training is focused on the agent's "weak spots". We present the design of CoachNet, explain its underlying principles, and empirically demonstrate its effectiveness in improving sample efficiency and test-time robustness in common continuous control tasks.

SMARTS: Scalable Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Training School for Autonomous Driving

Multi-agent interaction is a fundamental aspect of autonomous driving in the real world. Despite more than a decade of research and development, the problem of how to competently interact with diverse road users in diverse scenarios remains largely unsolved. Learning methods have much to offer towards solving this problem. But they require a realistic multi-agent simulator that generates diverse and competent driving interactions. To meet this need, we develop a dedicated simulation platform called SMARTS (Scalable Multi-Agent RL Training School). SMARTS supports the training, accumulation, and use of diverse behavior models of road users. These are in turn used to create increasingly more realistic and diverse interactions that enable deeper and broader research on multi-agent interaction. In this paper, we describe the design goals of SMARTS, explain its basic architecture and its key features, and illustrate its use through concrete multi-agent experiments on interactive scenarios. We open-source the SMARTS platform and the associated benchmark tasks and evaluation metrics to encourage and empower research on multi-agent learning for autonomous driving. Our code is available at https://github.com/huawei-noah/SMARTS.

Perception as prediction using general value functions in autonomous driving applications

We propose and demonstrate a framework called perception as prediction for autonomous driving that uses general value functions (GVFs) to learn predictions. Perception as prediction learns data-driven predictions relating to the impact of actions on the agent's perception of the world. It also provides a data-driven approach to predict the impact of the anticipated behavior of other agents on the world without explicitly learning their policy or intentions. We demonstrate perception as prediction by learning to predict an agent's front safety and rear safety with GVFs, which encapsulate anticipation of the behavior of the vehicle in front and in the rear, respectively. The safety predictions are learned through random interactions in a simulated environment containing other agents. We show that these predictions can be used to produce similar control behavior to an LQR-based controller in an adaptive cruise control problem as well as provide advanced warning when the vehicle behind is approaching dangerously. The predictions are compact policy-based predictions that support prediction of the long term impact on safety when following a given policy. We analyze two controllers that use the learned predictions in a racing simulator to understand the value of the predictions and demonstrate their use in the real-world on a Clearpath Jackal robot and an autonomous vehicle platform.