Evaluating Membership Inference Attacks and Defenses in Federated Learning

Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs) pose a growing threat to privacy preservation in federated learning. The semi-honest attacker, e.g., the server, may determine whether a particular sample belongs to a target client according to the observed model information. This paper conducts an evaluation of existing MIAs and corresponding defense strategies. Our evaluation on MIAs reveals two important findings about the trend of MIAs. Firstly, combining model information from multiple communication rounds (Multi-temporal) enhances the overall effectiveness of MIAs compared to utilizing model information from a single epoch. Secondly, incorporating models from non-target clients (Multi-spatial) significantly improves the effectiveness of MIAs, particularly when the clients' data is homogeneous. This highlights the importance of considering the temporal and spatial model information in MIAs. Next, we assess the effectiveness via privacy-utility tradeoff for two type defense mechanisms against MIAs: Gradient Perturbation and Data Replacement. Our results demonstrate that Data Replacement mechanisms achieve a more optimal balance between preserving privacy and maintaining model utility. Therefore, we recommend the adoption of Data Replacement methods as a defense strategy against MIAs. Our code is available in https://github.com/Liar-Mask/FedMIA.

FedSOV: Federated Model Secure Ownership Verification with Unforgeable Signature

Federated learning allows multiple parties to collaborate in learning a global model without revealing private data. The high cost of training and the significant value of the global model necessitates the need for ownership verification of federated learning. However, the existing ownership verification schemes in federated learning suffer from several limitations, such as inadequate support for a large number of clients and vulnerability to ambiguity attacks. To address these limitations, we propose a cryptographic signature-based federated learning model ownership verification scheme named FedSOV. FedSOV allows numerous clients to embed their ownership credentials and verify ownership using unforgeable digital signatures. The scheme provides theoretical resistance to ambiguity attacks with the unforgeability of the signature. Experimental results on computer vision and natural language processing tasks demonstrate that FedSOV is an effective federated model ownership verification scheme enhanced with provable cryptographic security.

FedZKP: Federated Model Ownership Verification with Zero-knowledge Proof

Federated learning (FL) allows multiple parties to cooperatively learn a federated model without sharing private data with each other. The need of protecting such federated models from being plagiarized or misused, therefore, motivates us to propose a provable secure model ownership verification scheme using zero-knowledge proof, named FedZKP. It is shown that the FedZKP scheme without disclosing credentials is guaranteed to defeat a variety of existing and potential attacks. Both theoretical analysis and empirical studies demonstrate the security of FedZKP in the sense that the probability for attackers to breach the proposed FedZKP is negligible. Moreover, extensive experimental results confirm the fidelity and robustness of our scheme.