The Singing Voice Conversion Challenge 2023

We present the latest iteration of the voice conversion challenge (VCC) series, a bi-annual scientific event aiming to compare and understand different voice conversion (VC) systems based on a common dataset. This year we shifted our focus to singing voice conversion (SVC), thus named the challenge the Singing Voice Conversion Challenge (SVCC). A new database was constructed for two tasks, namely in-domain and cross-domain SVC. The challenge was run for two months, and in total we received 26 submissions, including 2 baselines. Through a large-scale crowd-sourced listening test, we observed that for both tasks, although human-level naturalness was achieved by the top system, no team was able to obtain a similarity score as high as the target speakers. Also, as expected, cross-domain SVC is harder than in-domain SVC, especially in the similarity aspect. We also investigated whether existing objective measurements were able to predict perceptual performance, and found that only few of them could reach a significant correlation.

A Holistic Cascade System, benchmark, and Human Evaluation Protocol for Expressive Speech-to-Speech Translation

Expressive speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) aims to transfer prosodic attributes of source speech to target speech while maintaining translation accuracy. Existing research in expressive S2ST is limited, typically focusing on a single expressivity aspect at a time. Likewise, this research area lacks standard evaluation protocols and well-curated benchmark datasets. In this work, we propose a holistic cascade system for expressive S2ST, combining multiple prosody transfer techniques previously considered only in isolation. We curate a benchmark expressivity test set in the TV series domain and explored a second dataset in the audiobook domain. Finally, we present a human evaluation protocol to assess multiple expressive dimensions across speech pairs. Experimental results indicate that bi-lingual annotators can assess the quality of expressive preservation in S2ST systems, and the holistic modeling approach outperforms single-aspect systems. Audio samples can be accessed through our demo webpage: https://facebookresearch.github.io/speech_translation/cascade_expressive_s2st.

Intermediate Fine-Tuning Using Imperfect Synthetic Speech for Improving Electrolaryngeal Speech Recognition

Research on automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems for electrolaryngeal speakers has been relatively unexplored due to small datasets. When training data is lacking in ASR, a large-scale pretraining and fine tuning framework is often sufficient to achieve high recognition rates; however, in electrolaryngeal speech, the domain shift between the pretraining and fine-tuning data is too large to overcome, limiting the maximum improvement of recognition rates. To resolve this, we propose an intermediate fine-tuning step that uses imperfect synthetic speech to close the domain shift gap between the pretraining and target data. Despite the imperfect synthetic data, we show the effectiveness of this on electrolaryngeal speech datasets, with improvements of 6.1% over the baseline that did not use imperfect synthetic speech. Results show how the intermediate fine-tuning stage focuses on learning the high-level inherent features of the imperfect synthetic data rather than the low-level features such as intelligibility.

A Comparative Study of Self-supervised Speech Representation Based Voice Conversion

We present a large-scale comparative study of self-supervised speech representation (S3R)-based voice conversion (VC). In the context of recognition-synthesis VC, S3Rs are attractive owing to their potential to replace expensive supervised representations such as phonetic posteriorgrams (PPGs), which are commonly adopted by state-of-the-art VC systems. Using S3PRL-VC, an open-source VC software we previously developed, we provide a series of in-depth objective and subjective analyses under three VC settings: intra-/cross-lingual any-to-one (A2O) and any-to-any (A2A) VC, using the voice conversion challenge 2020 (VCC2020) dataset. We investigated S3R-based VC in various aspects, including model type, multilinguality, and supervision. We also studied the effect of a post-discretization process with k-means clustering and showed how it improves in the A2A setting. Finally, the comparison with state-of-the-art VC systems demonstrates the competitiveness of S3R-based VC and also sheds light on the possible improving directions.

Investigating Self-supervised Pretraining Frameworks for Pathological Speech Recognition

We investigate the performance of self-supervised pretraining frameworks on pathological speech datasets used for automatic speech recognition (ASR). Modern end-to-end models require thousands of hours of data to train well, but only a small number of pathological speech datasets are publicly available. A proven solution to this problem is by first pretraining the model on a huge number of healthy speech datasets and then fine-tuning it on the pathological speech datasets. One new pretraining framework called self-supervised learning (SSL) trains a network using only speech data, providing more flexibility in training data requirements and allowing more speech data to be used in pretraining. We investigate SSL frameworks such as the wav2vec 2.0 and WavLM models using different setups and compare their performance with different supervised pretraining setups, using two types of pathological speech, namely, Japanese electrolaryngeal and English dysarthric. Although the SSL setup is promising against Transformer-based supervised setups, other supervised setups such as the Conformer still outperform SSL pretraining. Our results show that the best supervised setup outperforms the best SSL setup by 13.9% character error rate in electrolaryngeal speech and 16.8% word error rate in dysarthric speech.

The VoiceMOS Challenge 2022

We present the first edition of the VoiceMOS Challenge, a scientific event that aims to promote the study of automatic prediction of the mean opinion score (MOS) of synthetic speech. This challenge drew 22 participating teams from academia and industry who tried a variety of approaches to tackle the problem of predicting human ratings of synthesized speech. The listening test data for the main track of the challenge consisted of samples from 187 different text-to-speech and voice conversion systems spanning over a decade of research, and the out-of-domain track consisted of data from more recent systems rated in a separate listening test. Results of the challenge show the effectiveness of fine-tuning self-supervised speech models for the MOS prediction task, as well as the difficulty of predicting MOS ratings for unseen speakers and listeners, and for unseen systems in the out-of-domain setting.

SUPERB-SG: Enhanced Speech processing Universal PERformance Benchmark for Semantic and Generative Capabilities

Transfer learning has proven to be crucial in advancing the state of speech and natural language processing research in recent years. In speech, a model pre-trained by self-supervised learning transfers remarkably well on multiple tasks. However, the lack of a consistent evaluation methodology is limiting towards a holistic understanding of the efficacy of such models. SUPERB was a step towards introducing a common benchmark to evaluate pre-trained models across various speech tasks. In this paper, we introduce SUPERB-SG, a new benchmark focused on evaluating the semantic and generative capabilities of pre-trained models by increasing task diversity and difficulty over SUPERB. We use a lightweight methodology to test the robustness of representations learned by pre-trained models under shifts in data domain and quality across different types of tasks. It entails freezing pre-trained model parameters, only using simple task-specific trainable heads. The goal is to be inclusive of all researchers, and encourage efficient use of computational resources. We also show that the task diversity of SUPERB-SG coupled with limited task supervision is an effective recipe for evaluating the generalizability of model representation.

Direct Noisy Speech Modeling for Noisy-to-Noisy Voice Conversion

Beyond the conventional voice conversion (VC) where the speaker information is converted without altering the linguistic content, the background sounds are informative and need to be retained in some real-world scenarios, such as VC in movie/video and VC in music where the voice is entangled with background sounds. As a new VC framework, we have developed a noisy-to-noisy (N2N) VC framework to convert the speaker's identity while preserving the background sounds. Although our framework consisting of a denoising module and a VC module well handles the background sounds, the VC module is sensitive to the distortion caused by the denoising module. To address this distortion issue, in this paper we propose the improved VC module to directly model the noisy speech waveform while controlling the background sounds. The experimental results have demonstrated that our improved framework significantly outperforms the previous one and achieves an acceptable score in terms of naturalness, while reaching comparable similarity performance to the upper bound of our framework.

LDNet: Unified Listener Dependent Modeling in MOS Prediction for Synthetic Speech

An effective approach to automatically predict the subjective rating for synthetic speech is to train on a listening test dataset with human-annotated scores. Although each speech sample in the dataset is rated by several listeners, most previous works only used the mean score as the training target. In this work, we present LDNet, a unified framework for mean opinion score (MOS) prediction that predicts the listener-wise perceived quality given the input speech and the listener identity. We reflect recent advances in LD modeling, including design choices of the model architecture, and propose two inference methods that provide more stable results and efficient computation. We conduct systematic experiments on the voice conversion challenge (VCC) 2018 benchmark and a newly collected large-scale MOS dataset, providing an in-depth analysis of the proposed framework. Results show that the mean listener inference method is a better way to utilize the mean scores, whose effectiveness is more obvious when having more ratings per sample.

Generalization Ability of MOS Prediction Networks

Automatic methods to predict listener opinions of synthesized speech remain elusive since listeners, systems being evaluated, characteristics of the speech, and even the instructions given and the rating scale all vary from test to test. While automatic predictors for metrics such as mean opinion score (MOS) can achieve high prediction accuracy on samples from the same test, they typically fail to generalize well to new listening test contexts. In this paper, using a variety of networks for MOS prediction including MOSNet and self-supervised speech models such as wav2vec2, we investigate their performance on data from different listening tests in both zero-shot and fine-tuned settings. We find that wav2vec2 models fine-tuned for MOS prediction have good generalization capability to out-of-domain data even for the most challenging case of utterance-level predictions in the zero-shot setting, and that fine-tuning to in-domain data can improve predictions. We also observe that unseen systems are especially challenging for MOS prediction models.