Banding vs. Quality: Perceptual Impact and Objective Assessment

Staircase-like contours introduced to a video by quantization in flat areas, commonly known as banding, have been a long-standing problem in both video processing and quality assessment communities. The fact that even a relatively small change of the original pixel values can result in a strong impact on perceived quality makes banding especially difficult to be detected by objective quality metrics. In this paper, we study how banding annoyance compares to more commonly studied scaling and compression artifacts with respect to the overall perceptual quality. We further propose a simple combination of VMAF and the recently developed banding index, CAMBI, into a banding-aware video quality metric showing improved correlation with overall perceived quality.

VMAF-based Bitrate Ladder Estimation for Adaptive Streaming

In HTTP Adaptive Streaming, video content is conventionally encoded by adapting its spatial resolution and quantization level to best match the prevailing network state and display characteristics. It is well known that the traditional solution, of using a fixed bitrate ladder, does not result in the highest quality of experience for the user. Hence, in this paper, we consider a content-driven approach for estimating the bitrate ladder, based on spatio-temporal features extracted from the uncompressed content. The method implements a content-driven interpolation. It uses the extracted features to train a machine learning model to infer the curvature points of the Rate-VMAF curves in order to guide a set of initial encodings. We employ the VMAF quality metric as a means of perceptually conditioning the estimation. When compared to exhaustive encoding that produces the reference ladder, the estimated ladder is composed by 74.3% of identical Rate-VMAF points with the reference ladder. The proposed method offers a significant reduction of the number of encodes required, 77.4%, at a small average Bj{\o}ntegaard Delta Rate cost, 1.12%.

Efficient Bitrate Ladder Construction for Content-Optimized Adaptive Video Streaming

One of the challenges faced by many video providers is the heterogeneity of network specifications, user requirements, and content compression performance. The universal solution of a fixed bitrate ladder is inadequate in ensuring a high quality of user experience without re-buffering or introducing annoying compression artifacts. However, a content-tailored solution, based on extensively encoding across all resolutions and over a wide quality range is highly expensive in terms of computational, financial, and energy costs. Inspired by this, we propose an approach that exploits machine learning to predict a content-optimized bitrate ladder. The method extracts spatio-temporal features from the uncompressed content, trains machine-learning models to predict the Pareto front parameters, and, based on that, builds the ladder within a defined bitrate range. The method has the benefit of significantly reducing the number of encodes required per sequence. The presented results, based on 100 HEVC-encoded sequences, demonstrate a reduction in the number of encodes required when compared to an exhaustive search and an interpolation-based method, by 89.06% and 61.46%, respectively, at the cost of an average Bj{\o}ntegaard Delta Rate difference of 1.78% compared to the exhaustive approach. Finally, a hybrid method is introduced that selects either the proposed or the interpolation-based method depending on the sequence features. This results in an overall 83.83% reduction of required encodings at the cost of an average Bj{\o}ntegaard Delta Rate difference of 1.26%.

CAMBI: Contrast-aware Multiscale Banding Index

Banding artifacts are artificially-introduced contours arising from the quantization of a smooth region in a video. Despite the advent of recent higher quality video systems with more efficient codecs, these artifacts remain conspicuous, especially on larger displays. In this work, a comprehensive subjective study is performed to understand the dependence of the banding visibility on encoding parameters and dithering. We subsequently develop a simple and intuitive no-reference banding index called CAMBI (Contrast-aware Multiscale Banding Index) which uses insights from Contrast Sensitivity Function in the Human Visual System to predict banding visibility. CAMBI correlates well with subjective perception of banding while using only a few visually-motivated hyperparameters.