We introduce a new benchmarking suite for high-dimensional control, targeted at testing high spatial and temporal precision, coordination, and planning, all with an underactuated system frequently making-and-breaking contacts. The proposed challenge is mastering the piano through bi-manual dexterity, using a pair of simulated anthropomorphic robot hands. We call it RoboPianist, and the initial version covers a broad set of 150 variable-difficulty songs. We investigate both model-free and model-based methods on the benchmark, characterizing their performance envelopes. We observe that while certain existing methods, when well-tuned, can achieve impressive levels of performance in certain aspects, there is significant room for improvement. RoboPianist provides a rich quantitative benchmarking environment, with human-interpretable results, high ease of expansion by simply augmenting the repertoire with new songs, and opportunities for further research, including in multi-task learning, zero-shot generalization, multimodal (sound, vision, touch) learning, and imitation. Supplementary information, including videos of our control policies, can be found at https://kzakka.com/robopianist/