From "Where" to "What": Towards Human-Understandable Explanations through Concept Relevance Propagation

The emerging field of eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) aims to bring transparency to today's powerful but opaque deep learning models. While local XAI methods explain individual predictions in form of attribution maps, thereby identifying where important features occur (but not providing information about what they represent), global explanation techniques visualize what concepts a model has generally learned to encode. Both types of methods thus only provide partial insights and leave the burden of interpreting the model's reasoning to the user. Only few contemporary techniques aim at combining the principles behind both local and global XAI for obtaining more informative explanations. Those methods, however, are often limited to specific model architectures or impose additional requirements on training regimes or data and label availability, which renders the post-hoc application to arbitrarily pre-trained models practically impossible. In this work we introduce the Concept Relevance Propagation (CRP) approach, which combines the local and global perspectives of XAI and thus allows answering both the "where" and "what" questions for individual predictions, without additional constraints imposed. We further introduce the principle of Relevance Maximization for finding representative examples of encoded concepts based on their usefulness to the model. We thereby lift the dependency on the common practice of Activation Maximization and its limitations. We demonstrate the capabilities of our methods in various settings, showcasing that Concept Relevance Propagation and Relevance Maximization lead to more human interpretable explanations and provide deep insights into the model's representations and reasoning through concept atlases, concept composition analyses, and quantitative investigations of concept subspaces and their role in fine-grained decision making.

Explain to Not Forget: Defending Against Catastrophic Forgetting with XAI

The ability to continuously process and retain new information like we do naturally as humans is a feat that is highly sought after when training neural networks. Unfortunately, the traditional optimization algorithms often require large amounts of data available during training time and updates wrt. new data are difficult after the training process has been completed. In fact, when new data or tasks arise, previous progress may be lost as neural networks are prone to catastrophic forgetting. Catastrophic forgetting describes the phenomenon when a neural network completely forgets previous knowledge when given new information. We propose a novel training algorithm called training by explaining in which we leverage Layer-wise Relevance Propagation in order to retain the information a neural network has already learned in previous tasks when training on new data. The method is evaluated on a range of benchmark datasets as well as more complex data. Our method not only successfully retains the knowledge of old tasks within the neural networks but does so more resource-efficiently than other state-of-the-art solutions.

But that's not why: Inference adjustment by interactive prototype deselection

Despite significant advances in machine learning, decision-making of artificial agents is still not perfect and often requires post-hoc human interventions. If the prediction of a model relies on unreasonable factors it is desirable to remove their effect. Deep interactive prototype adjustment enables the user to give hints and correct the model's reasoning. In this paper, we demonstrate that prototypical-part models are well suited for this task as their prediction is based on prototypical image patches that can be interpreted semantically by the user. It shows that even correct classifications can rely on unreasonable prototypes that result from confounding variables in a dataset. Hence, we propose simple yet effective interaction schemes for inference adjustment: The user is consulted interactively to identify faulty prototypes. Non-object prototypes can be removed by prototype masking or a custom mode of deselection training. Interactive prototype rejection allows machine learning na\"{i}ve users to adjust the logic of reasoning without compromising the accuracy.

Beyond Explaining: Opportunities and Challenges of XAI-Based Model Improvement

Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) is an emerging research field bringing transparency to highly complex and opaque machine learning (ML) models. Despite the development of a multitude of methods to explain the decisions of black-box classifiers in recent years, these tools are seldomly used beyond visualization purposes. Only recently, researchers have started to employ explanations in practice to actually improve models. This paper offers a comprehensive overview over techniques that apply XAI practically for improving various properties of ML models, and systematically categorizes these approaches, comparing their respective strengths and weaknesses. We provide a theoretical perspective on these methods, and show empirically through experiments on toy and realistic settings how explanations can help improve properties such as model generalization ability or reasoning, among others. We further discuss potential caveats and drawbacks of these methods. We conclude that while model improvement based on XAI can have significant beneficial effects even on complex and not easily quantifyable model properties, these methods need to be applied carefully, since their success can vary depending on a multitude of factors, such as the model and dataset used, or the employed explanation method.

Quantus: An Explainable AI Toolkit for Responsible Evaluation of Neural Network Explanations

The evaluation of explanation methods is a research topic that has not yet been explored deeply, however, since explainability is supposed to strengthen trust in artificial intelligence, it is necessary to systematically review and compare explanation methods in order to confirm their correctness. Until now, no tool exists that exhaustively and speedily allows researchers to quantitatively evaluate explanations of neural network predictions. To increase transparency and reproducibility in the field, we therefore built Quantus - a comprehensive, open-source toolkit in Python that includes a growing, well-organised collection of evaluation metrics and tutorials for evaluating explainable methods. The toolkit has been thoroughly tested and is available under open source license on PyPi (or on https://github.com/understandable-machine-intelligence-lab/quantus/).

Measurably Stronger Explanation Reliability via Model Canonization

While rule-based attribution methods have proven useful for providing local explanations for Deep Neural Networks, explaining modern and more varied network architectures yields new challenges in generating trustworthy explanations, since the established rule sets might not be sufficient or applicable to novel network structures. As an elegant solution to the above issue, network canonization has recently been introduced. This procedure leverages the implementation-dependency of rule-based attributions and restructures a model into a functionally identical equivalent of alternative design to which established attribution rules can be applied. However, the idea of canonization and its usefulness have so far only been explored qualitatively. In this work, we quantitatively verify the beneficial effects of network canonization to rule-based attributions on VGG-16 and ResNet18 models with BatchNorm layers and thus extend the current best practices for obtaining reliable neural network explanations.

PatClArC: Using Pattern Concept Activation Vectors for Noise-Robust Model Debugging

State-of-the-art machine learning models are commonly (pre-)trained on large benchmark datasets. These often contain biases, artifacts, or errors that have remained unnoticed in the data collection process and therefore fail in representing the real world truthfully. This can cause models trained on these datasets to learn undesired behavior based upon spurious correlations, e.g., the existence of a copyright tag in an image. Concept Activation Vectors (CAV) have been proposed as a tool to model known concepts in latent space and have been used for concept sensitivity testing and model correction. Specifically, class artifact compensation (ClArC) corrects models using CAVs to represent data artifacts in feature space linearly. Modeling CAVs with filters of linear models, however, causes a significant influence of the noise portion within the data, as recent work proposes the unsuitability of linear model filters to find the signal direction in the input, which can be avoided by instead using patterns. In this paper we propose Pattern Concept Activation Vectors (PCAV) for noise-robust concept representations in latent space. We demonstrate that pattern-based artifact modeling has beneficial effects on the application of CAVs as a means to remove influence of confounding features from models via the ClArC framework.

ECQ$^{\text{x}}$: Explainability-Driven Quantization for Low-Bit and Sparse DNNs

The remarkable success of deep neural networks (DNNs) in various applications is accompanied by a significant increase in network parameters and arithmetic operations. Such increases in memory and computational demands make deep learning prohibitive for resource-constrained hardware platforms such as mobile devices. Recent efforts aim to reduce these overheads, while preserving model performance as much as possible, and include parameter reduction techniques, parameter quantization, and lossless compression techniques. In this chapter, we develop and describe a novel quantization paradigm for DNNs: Our method leverages concepts of explainable AI (XAI) and concepts of information theory: Instead of assigning weight values based on their distances to the quantization clusters, the assignment function additionally considers weight relevances obtained from Layer-wise Relevance Propagation (LRP) and the information content of the clusters (entropy optimization). The ultimate goal is to preserve the most relevant weights in quantization clusters of highest information content. Experimental results show that this novel Entropy-Constrained and XAI-adjusted Quantization (ECQ$^{\text{x}}$) method generates ultra low-precision (2-5 bit) and simultaneously sparse neural networks while maintaining or even improving model performance. Due to reduced parameter precision and high number of zero-elements, the rendered networks are highly compressible in terms of file size, up to $103\times$ compared to the full-precision unquantized DNN model. Our approach was evaluated on different types of models and datasets (including Google Speech Commands and CIFAR-10) and compared with previous work.

Software for Dataset-wide XAI: From Local Explanations to Global Insights with Zennit, CoRelAy, and ViRelAy

Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) are known to be strong predictors, but their prediction strategies can rarely be understood. With recent advances in Explainable Artificial Intelligence, approaches are available to explore the reasoning behind those complex models' predictions. One class of approaches are post-hoc attribution methods, among which Layer-wise Relevance Propagation (LRP) shows high performance. However, the attempt at understanding a DNN's reasoning often stops at the attributions obtained for individual samples in input space, leaving the potential for deeper quantitative analyses untouched. As a manual analysis without the right tools is often unnecessarily labor intensive, we introduce three software packages targeted at scientists to explore model reasoning using attribution approaches and beyond: (1) Zennit - a highly customizable and intuitive attribution framework implementing LRP and related approaches in PyTorch, (2) CoRelAy - a framework to easily and quickly construct quantitative analysis pipelines for dataset-wide analyses of explanations, and (3) ViRelAy - a web-application to interactively explore data, attributions, and analysis results.