Image Fusion in Remote Sensing: An Overview and Meta Analysis

Image fusion in Remote Sensing (RS) has been a consistent demand due to its ability to turn raw images of different resolutions, sources, and modalities into accurate, complete, and spatio-temporally coherent images. It greatly facilitates downstream applications such as pan-sharpening, change detection, land-cover classification, etc. Yet, image fusion solutions are highly disparate to various remote sensing problems and thus are often narrowly defined in existing reviews as topical applications, such as pan-sharpening, and spatial-temporal image fusion. Considering that image fusion can be theoretically applied to any gridded data through pixel-level operations, in this paper, we expanded its scope by comprehensively surveying relevant works with a simple taxonomy: 1) many-to-one image fusion; 2) many-to-many image fusion. This simple taxonomy defines image fusion as a mapping problem that turns either a single or a set of images into another single or set of images, depending on the desired coherence, e.g., spectral, spatial/resolution coherence, etc. We show that this simple taxonomy, despite the significant modality difference it covers, can be presented by a conceptually easy framework. In addition, we provide a meta-analysis to review the major papers studying the various types of image fusion and their applications over the years (from the 1980s to date), covering 5,926 peer-reviewed papers. Finally, we discuss the main benefits and emerging challenges to provide open research directions and potential future works.

Enabling Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) for Large-scale Aerial Images -- A Multi-tiling Approach and the Geometry Assessment of NeRF

Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) offer the potential to benefit 3D reconstruction tasks, including aerial photogrammetry. However, the scalability and accuracy of the inferred geometry are not well-documented for large-scale aerial assets,since such datasets usually result in very high memory consumption and slow convergence.. In this paper, we aim to scale the NeRF on large-scael aerial datasets and provide a thorough geometry assessment of NeRF. Specifically, we introduce a location-specific sampling technique as well as a multi-camera tiling (MCT) strategy to reduce memory consumption during image loading for RAM, representation training for GPU memory, and increase the convergence rate within tiles. MCT decomposes a large-frame image into multiple tiled images with different camera models, allowing these small-frame images to be fed into the training process as needed for specific locations without a loss of accuracy. We implement our method on a representative approach, Mip-NeRF, and compare its geometry performance with threephotgrammetric MVS pipelines on two typical aerial datasets against LiDAR reference data. Both qualitative and quantitative results suggest that the proposed NeRF approach produces better completeness and object details than traditional approaches, although as of now, it still falls short in terms of accuracy.

On the Transferability of Learning Models for Semantic Segmentation for Remote Sensing Data

Recent deep learning-based methods outperform traditional learning methods on remote sensing (RS) semantic segmentation/classification tasks. However, they require large training datasets and are generally known for lack of transferability due to the highly disparate RS image content across different geographical regions. Yet, there is no comprehensive analysis of their transferability, i.e., to which extent a model trained on a source domain can be readily applicable to a target domain. Therefore, in this paper, we aim to investigate the raw transferability of traditional and deep learning (DL) models, as well as the effectiveness of domain adaptation (DA) approaches in enhancing the transferability of the DL models (adapted transferability). By utilizing four highly diverse RS datasets, we train six models with and without three DA approaches to analyze their transferability between these datasets quantitatively. Furthermore, we developed a straightforward method to quantify the transferability of a model using the spectral indices as a medium and have demonstrated its effectiveness in evaluating the model transferability at the target domain when the labels are unavailable. Our experiments yield several generally important yet not well-reported observations regarding the raw and adapted transferability. Moreover, our proposed label-free transferability assessment method is validated to be better than posterior model confidence. The findings can guide the future development of generalized RS learning models. The trained models are released under this link: https://github.com/GDAOSU/Transferability-Remote-Sensing

Enabling Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) for Large-scale Aerial Images -- A Multi-tiling Approaching and the Geometry Assessment of NeRF

Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) offer the potential to benefit 3D reconstruction tasks, including aerial photogrammetry. However, the scalability and accuracy of the inferred geometry are not well-documented for large-scale aerial assets,since such datasets usually result in very high memory consumption and slow convergence.. In this paper, we aim to scale the NeRF on large-scael aerial datasets and provide a thorough geometry assessment of NeRF. Specifically, we introduce a location-specific sampling technique as well as a multi-camera tiling (MCT) strategy to reduce memory consumption during image loading for RAM, representation training for GPU memory, and increase the convergence rate within tiles. MCT decomposes a large-frame image into multiple tiled images with different camera models, allowing these small-frame images to be fed into the training process as needed for specific locations without a loss of accuracy. We implement our method on a representative approach, Mip-NeRF, and compare its geometry performance with threephotgrammetric MVS pipelines on two typical aerial datasets against LiDAR reference data. Both qualitative and quantitative results suggest that the proposed NeRF approach produces better completeness and object details than traditional approaches, although as of now, it still falls short in terms of accuracy.

a critical analysis of internal reliability for uncertainty quantification of dense image matching in multi-view stereo

Nowadays, photogrammetrically derived point clouds are widely used in many civilian applications due to their low cost and flexibility in acquisition. Typically, photogrammetric point clouds are assessed through reference data such as LiDAR point clouds. However, when reference data are not available, the assessment of photogrammetric point clouds may be challenging. Since these point clouds are algorithmically derived, their accuracies and precisions are highly varying with the camera networks, scene complexity, and dense image matching (DIM) algorithms, and there is no standard error metric to determine per-point errors. The theory of internal reliability of camera networks has been well studied through first-order error estimation of Bundle Adjustment (BA), which is used to understand the errors of 3D points assuming known measurement errors. However, the measurement errors of the DIM algorithms are intricate to an extent that every single point may have its error function determined by factors such as pixel intensity, texture entropy, and surface smoothness. Despite the complexity, there exist a few common metrics that may aid the process of estimating the posterior reliability of the derived points, especially in a multi-view stereo (MVS) setup when redundancies are present. In this paper, by using an aerial oblique photogrammetric block with LiDAR reference data, we analyze several internal matching metrics within a common MVS framework, including statistics in ray convergence, intersection angles, DIM energy, etc.

Mesh Conflation of Oblique Photogrammetric Models using Virtual Cameras and Truncated Signed Distance Field

Conflating/stitching 2.5D raster digital surface models (DSM) into a large one has been a running practice in geoscience applications, however, conflating full-3D mesh models, such as those from oblique photogrammetry, is extremely challenging. In this letter, we propose a novel approach to address this challenge by conflating multiple full-3D oblique photogrammetric models into a single, and seamless mesh for high-resolution site modeling. Given two or more individually collected and created photogrammetric meshes, we first propose to create a virtual camera field (with a panoramic field of view) to incubate virtual spaces represented by Truncated Signed Distance Field (TSDF), an implicit volumetric field friendly for linear 3D fusion; then we adaptively leverage the truncated bound of meshes in TSDF to conflate them into a single and accurate full 3D site model. With drone-based 3D meshes, we show that our approach significantly improves upon traditional methods for model conflations, to drive new potentials to create excessively large and accurate full 3D mesh models in support of geoscience and environmental applications.

Select-and-Combine (SAC): A Novel Multi-Stereo Depth Fusion Algorithm for Point Cloud Generation via Efficient Local Markov Netlets

Many practical systems for image-based surface reconstruction employ a stereo/multi-stereo paradigm, due to its ability to scale for large scenes and its ease of implementation for out-of-core operations. In this process, multiple and abundant depth maps from stereo matching must be combined and fused into a single, consistent, and clean point cloud. However, the noises and outliers caused by stereo matching and the heterogenous geometric errors of the poses present a challenge for existing fusion algorithms, since they mostly assume Gaussian errors and predict fused results based on data from local spatial neighborhoods, which may inherit uncertainties from multiple depths resulting in lowered accuracy. In this paper, we propose a novel depth fusion paradigm, that instead of numerically fusing points from multiple depth maps, selects the best depth map per point, and combines them into a single and clean point cloud. This paradigm, called select-and-combine (SAC), is achieved through modeling the point level fusion using local Markov Netlets, a micro-network over point across neighboring views for depth/view selection, followed by a Netlets collapse process for point combination. The Markov Netlets are optimized such that they can inherently leverage spatial consistencies among depth maps of neighboring views, thus they can address errors beyond Gaussian ones. Our experiment results show that our approach outperforms existing depth fusion approaches by increasing the F1 score that considers both accuracy and completeness by 2.07% compared to the best existing method. Finally, our approach generates clearer point clouds that are 18% less redundant while with a higher accuracy before fusion

Large-scale and Efficient Texture Mapping Algorithm via Loopy Belief Propagation

Texture mapping as a fundamental task in 3D modeling has been well established for well-acquired aerial assets under consistent illumination, yet it remains a challenge when it is scaled to large datasets with images under varying views and illuminations. A well-performed texture mapping algorithm must be able to efficiently select views, fuse and map textures from these views to mesh models, at the same time, achieve consistent radiometry over the entire model. Existing approaches achieve efficiency either by limiting the number of images to one view per face, or simplifying global inferences to only achieve local color consistency. In this paper, we break this tie by proposing a novel and efficient texture mapping framework that allows the use of multiple views of texture per face, at the same time to achieve global color consistency. The proposed method leverages a loopy belief propagation algorithm to perform an efficient and global-level probabilistic inferences to rank candidate views per face, which enables face-level multi-view texture fusion and blending. The texture fusion algorithm, being non-parametric, brings another advantage over typical parametric post color correction methods, due to its improved robustness to non-linear illumination differences. The experiments on three different types of datasets (i.e. satellite dataset, unmanned-aerial vehicle dataset and close-range dataset) show that the proposed method has produced visually pleasant and texturally consistent results in all scenarios, with an added advantage of consuming less running time as compared to the state of the art methods, especially for large-scale dataset such as satellite-derived models.

Point Cloud Registration for LiDAR and Photogrammetric Data: a Critical Synthesis and Performance Analysis on Classic and Deep Learning Algorithms

Recent advances in computer vision and deep learning have shown promising performance in estimating rigid/similarity transformation between unregistered point clouds of complex objects and scenes. However, their performances are mostly evaluated using a limited number of datasets from a single sensor (e.g. Kinect or RealSense cameras), lacking a comprehensive overview of their applicability in photogrammetric 3D mapping scenarios. In this work, we provide a comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art (SOTA) point cloud registration methods, where we analyze and evaluate these methods using a diverse set of point cloud data from indoor to satellite sources. The quantitative analysis allows for exploring the strengths, applicability, challenges, and future trends of these methods. In contrast to existing analysis works that introduce point cloud registration as a holistic process, our experimental analysis is based on its inherent two-step process to better comprehend these approaches including feature/keypoint-based initial coarse registration and dense fine registration through cloud-to-cloud (C2C) optimization. More than ten methods, including classic hand-crafted, deep-learning-based feature correspondence, and robust C2C methods were tested. We observed that the success rate of most of the algorithms are fewer than 40% over the datasets we tested and there are still are large margin of improvement upon existing algorithms concerning 3D sparse corresopondence search, and the ability to register point clouds with complex geometry and occlusions. With the evaluated statistics on three datasets, we conclude the best-performing methods for each step and provide our recommendations, and outlook future efforts.

A Comparative Study on Deep-Learning Methods for Dense Image Matching of Multi-angle and Multi-date Remote Sensing Stereo Images

Deep learning (DL) stereo matching methods gained great attention in remote sensing satellite datasets. However, most of these existing studies conclude assessments based only on a few/single stereo images lacking a systematic evaluation on how robust DL methods are on satellite stereo images with varying radiometric and geometric configurations. This paper provides an evaluation of four DL stereo matching methods through hundreds of multi-date multi-site satellite stereo pairs with varying geometric configurations, against the traditional well-practiced Census-SGM (Semi-global matching), to comprehensively understand their accuracy, robustness, generalization capabilities, and their practical potential. The DL methods include a learning-based cost metric through convolutional neural networks (MC-CNN) followed by SGM, and three end-to-end (E2E) learning models using Geometry and Context Network (GCNet), Pyramid Stereo Matching Network (PSMNet), and LEAStereo. Our experiments show that E2E algorithms can achieve upper limits of geometric accuracies, while may not generalize well for unseen data. The learning-based cost metric and Census-SGM are rather robust and can consistently achieve acceptable results. All DL algorithms are robust to geometric configurations of stereo pairs and are less sensitive in comparison to the Census-SGM, while learning-based cost metrics can generalize on satellite images when trained on different datasets (airborne or ground-view).