The Implications of Decentralization in Blockchained Federated Learning: Evaluating the Impact of Model Staleness and Inconsistencies

Blockchain promises to enhance distributed machine learning (ML) approaches such as federated learning (FL) by providing further decentralization, security, immutability, and trust, which are key properties for enabling collaborative intelligence in next-generation applications. Nonetheless, the intrinsic decentralized operation of peer-to-peer (P2P) blockchain nodes leads to an uncharted setting for FL, whereby the concepts of FL round and global model become meaningless, as devices' synchronization is lost without the figure of a central orchestrating server. In this paper, we study the practical implications of outsourcing the orchestration of FL to a democratic network such as in a blockchain. In particular, we focus on the effects that model staleness and inconsistencies, endorsed by blockchains' modus operandi, have on the training procedure held by FL devices asynchronously. Using simulation, we evaluate the blockchained FL operation on the well-known CIFAR-10 dataset and focus on the accuracy and timeliness of the solutions. Our results show the high impact of model inconsistencies on the accuracy of the models (up to a ~35% decrease in prediction accuracy), which underscores the importance of properly designing blockchain systems based on the characteristics of the underlying FL application.

AI/ML-based Load Prediction in IEEE 802.11 Enterprise Networks

Enterprise Wi-Fi networks can greatly benefit from Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (AI/ML) thanks to their well-developed management and operation capabilities. At the same time, AI/ML-based traffic/load prediction is one of the most appealing data-driven solutions to improve the Wi-Fi experience, either through the enablement of autonomous operation or by boosting troubleshooting with forecasted network utilization. In this paper, we study the suitability and feasibility of adopting AI/ML-based load prediction in practical enterprise Wi-Fi networks. While leveraging AI/ML solutions can potentially contribute to optimizing Wi-Fi networks in terms of energy efficiency, performance, and reliability, their effective adoption is constrained to aspects like data availability and quality, computational capabilities, and energy consumption. Our results show that hardware-constrained AI/ML models can potentially predict network load with less than 20% average error and 3% 85th-percentile error, which constitutes a suitable input for proactively driving Wi-Fi network optimization.

Towards Energy-Aware Federated Traffic Prediction for Cellular Networks

Cellular traffic prediction is a crucial activity for optimizing networks in fifth-generation (5G) networks and beyond, as accurate forecasting is essential for intelligent network design, resource allocation and anomaly mitigation. Although machine learning (ML) is a promising approach to effectively predict network traffic, the centralization of massive data in a single data center raises issues regarding confidentiality, privacy and data transfer demands. To address these challenges, federated learning (FL) emerges as an appealing ML training framework which offers high accurate predictions through parallel distributed computations. However, the environmental impact of these methods is often overlooked, which calls into question their sustainability. In this paper, we address the trade-off between accuracy and energy consumption in FL by proposing a novel sustainability indicator that allows assessing the feasibility of ML models. Then, we comprehensively evaluate state-of-the-art deep learning (DL) architectures in a federated scenario using real-world measurements from base station (BS) sites in the area of Barcelona, Spain. Our findings indicate that larger ML models achieve marginally improved performance but have a significant environmental impact in terms of carbon footprint, which make them impractical for real-world applications.

Throughput Analysis of IEEE 802.11bn Coordinated Spatial Reuse

Multi-Access Point Coordination (MAPC) is becoming the cornerstone of the IEEE 802.11bn amendment, alias Wi-Fi 8. Among the MAPC features, Coordinated Spatial Reuse (C-SR) stands as one of the most appealing due to its capability to orchestrate simultaneous access point transmissions at a low implementation complexity. In this paper, we contribute to the understanding of C-SR by introducing an analytical model based on Continuous Time Markov Chains (CTMCs) to characterize its throughput and spatial efficiency. Applying the proposed model to several network topologies, we show that C-SR opportunistically enables parallel high-quality transmissions and yields an average throughput gain of up to 59% in comparison to the legacy 802.11 Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) and up to 42% when compared to the 802.11ax Overlapping Basic Service Set Packet Detect (OBSS/PD) mechanism.

How Much Does It Cost to Train a Machine Learning Model over Distributed Data Sources?

Federated learning (FL) is one of the most appealing alternatives to the standard centralized learning paradigm, allowing heterogeneous set of devices to train a machine learning model without sharing their raw data. However, FL requires a central server to coordinate the learning process, thus introducing potential scalability and security issues. In the literature, server-less FL approaches like gossip federated learning (GFL) and blockchain-enabled federated learning (BFL) have been proposed to mitigate these issues. In this work, we propose a complete overview of these three techniques proposing a comparison according to an integral set of performance indicators, including model accuracy, time complexity, communication overhead, convergence time and energy consumption. An extensive simulation campaign permits to draw a quantitative analysis. In particular, GFL is able to save the 18% of training time, the 68% of energy and the 51% of data to be shared with respect to the CFL solution, but it is not able to reach the level of accuracy of CFL. On the other hand, BFL represents a viable solution for implementing decentralized learning with a higher level of security, at the cost of an extra energy usage and data sharing. Finally, we identify open issues on the two decentralized federated learning implementations and provide insights on potential extensions and possible research directions on this new research field.

On the Decentralization of Blockchain-enabled Asynchronous Federated Learning

Federated learning (FL), thanks in part to the emergence of the edge computing paradigm, is expected to enable true real-time applications in production environments. However, its original dependence on a central server for orchestration raises several concerns in terms of security, privacy, and scalability. To solve some of these worries, blockchain technology is expected to bring decentralization, robustness, and enhanced trust to FL. The empowerment of FL through blockchain (also referred to as FLchain), however, has some implications in terms of ledger inconsistencies and age of information (AoI), which are naturally inherited from the blockchain's fully decentralized operation. Such issues stem from the fact that, given the temporary ledger versions in the blockchain, FL devices may use different models for training, and that, given the asynchronicity of the FL operation, stale local updates (computed using outdated models) may be generated. In this paper, we shed light on the implications of the FLchain setting and study the effect that both the AoI and ledger inconsistencies have on the FL performance. To that end, we provide a faithful simulation tool that allows capturing the decentralized and asynchronous nature of the FLchain operation.

Federated Spatial Reuse Optimization in Next-Generation Decentralized IEEE 802.11 WLANs

As wireless standards evolve, more complex functionalities are introduced to address the increasing requirements in terms of throughput, latency, security, and efficiency. To unleash the potential of such new features, artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are currently being exploited for deriving models and protocols from data, rather than by hand-programming. In this paper, we explore the feasibility of applying ML in next-generation wireless local area networks (WLANs). More specifically, we focus on the IEEE 802.11ax spatial reuse (SR) problem and predict its performance through federated learning (FL) models. The set of FL solutions overviewed in this work is part of the 2021 International Telecommunication Union (ITU) AI for 5G Challenge.

Blockchain-enabled Server-less Federated Learning

Motivated by the heterogeneous nature of devices participating in large-scale Federated Learning (FL) optimization, we focus on an asynchronous server-less FL solution empowered by Blockchain (BC) technology. In contrast to mostly adopted FL approaches, which assume synchronous operation, we advocate an asynchronous method whereby model aggregation is done as clients submit their local updates. The asynchronous setting fits well with the federated optimization idea in practical large-scale settings with heterogeneous clients. Thus, it potentially leads to higher efficiency in terms of communication overhead and idle periods. To evaluate the learning completion delay of BC-enabled FL, we provide an analytical model based on batch service queue theory. Furthermore, we provide simulation results to assess the performance of both synchronous and asynchronous mechanisms. Important aspects involved in the BC-enabled FL optimization, such as the network size, link capacity, or user requirements, are put together and analyzed. As our results show, the synchronous setting leads to higher prediction accuracy than the asynchronous case. Nevertheless, asynchronous federated optimization provides much lower latency in many cases, thus becoming an appealing FL solution when dealing with large data sets, tough timing constraints (e.g., near-real-time applications), or highly varying training data.

Machine Learning for Performance Prediction of Channel Bonding in Next-Generation IEEE 802.11 WLANs

With the advent of Artificial Intelligence (AI)-empowered communications, industry, academia, and standardization organizations are progressing on the definition of mechanisms and procedures to address the increasing complexity of future 5G and beyond communications. In this context, the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) organized the first AI for 5G Challenge to bring industry and academia together to introduce and solve representative problems related to the application of Machine Learning (ML) to networks. In this paper, we present the results gathered from Problem Statement~13 (PS-013), organized by Universitat Pompeu Fabra (UPF), which primary goal was predicting the performance of next-generation Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) applying Channel Bonding (CB) techniques. In particular, we overview the ML models proposed by participants (including Artificial Neural Networks, Graph Neural Networks, Random Forest regression, and gradient boosting) and analyze their performance on an open dataset generated using the IEEE 802.11ax-oriented Komondor network simulator. The accuracy achieved by the proposed methods demonstrates the suitability of ML for predicting the performance of WLANs. Moreover, we discuss the importance of abstracting WLAN interactions to achieve better results, and we argue that there is certainly room for improvement in throughput prediction through ML.

Usage of Network Simulators in Machine-Learning-Assisted 5G/6G Networks

Without any doubt, Machine Learning (ML) will be an important driver of future communications due to its foreseen performance in front of complex problems. However, the application of ML to networking systems raises concerns among network operators and other stakeholders, especially regarding trustworthiness and reliability. In this paper, we devise the role of network simulators for bridging the gap between ML and communications systems. Network simulators can facilitate the adoption of ML-based solutions by means of training, testing, and validating ML models before being applied to an operative network. Finally, we showcase the potential benefits of integrating network simulators into ML-assisted communications through a proof-of-concept testbed implementation of a residential Wi-Fi network.