A Study on the Use of Simulation in Synthesizing Path-Following Control Policies for Autonomous Ground Robots

We report results obtained and insights gained while answering the following question: how effective is it to use a simulator to establish path following control policies for an autonomous ground robot? While the quality of the simulator conditions the answer to this question, we found that for the simulation platform used herein, producing four control policies for path planning was straightforward once a digital twin of the controlled robot was available. The control policies established in simulation and subsequently demonstrated in the real world are PID control, MPC, and two neural network (NN) based controllers. Training the two NN controllers via imitation learning was accomplished expeditiously using seven simple maneuvers: follow three circles clockwise, follow the same circles counter-clockwise, and drive straight. A test randomization process that employs random micro-simulations is used to rank the ``goodness'' of the four control policies. The policy ranking noted in simulation correlates well with the ranking observed when the control policies were tested in the real world. The simulation platform used is publicly available and BSD3-released as open source; a public Docker image is available for reproducibility studies. It contains a dynamics engine, a sensor simulator, a ROS2 bridge, and a ROS2 autonomy stack the latter employed both in the simulator and the real world experiments.

Quantifying the Sim2real Gap for GPS and IMU Sensors

Simulation can and should play a critical role in the development and testing of algorithms for autonomous agents. What might reduce its impact is the ``sim2real'' gap -- the algorithm response differs between operation in simulated versus real-world environments. This paper introduces an approach to evaluate this gap, focusing on the accuracy of sensor simulation -- specifically IMU and GPS -- in velocity estimation tasks for autonomous agents. Using a scaled autonomous vehicle, we conduct 40 real-world experiments across diverse environments then replicate the experiments in simulation with five distinct sensor noise models. We note that direct comparison of raw simulation and real sensor data fails to quantify the sim2real gap for robotics applications. We demonstrate that by using a state of the art state-estimation package as a ``judge'', and by evaluating the performance of this state-estimator in both real and simulated scenarios, we can isolate the sim2real discrepancies stemming from sensor simulations alone. The dataset generated is open-source and publicly available for unfettered use.

POLAR3D: Augmenting NASA's POLAR Dataset for Data-Driven Lunar Perception and Rover Simulation

We report on an effort that led to POLAR3D, a set of digital assets that enhance the POLAR dataset of stereo images generated by NASA to mimic lunar lighting conditions. Our contributions are twofold. First, we have annotated each photo in the POLAR dataset, providing approximately 23 000 labels for rocks and their shadows. Second, we digitized several lunar terrain scenarios available in the POLAR dataset. Specifically, by utilizing both the lunar photos and the POLAR's LiDAR point clouds, we constructed detailed obj files for all identifiable assets. POLAR3D is the set of digital assets comprising of rock/shadow labels and obj files associated with the digital twins of lunar terrain scenarios. This new dataset can be used for training perception algorithms for lunar exploration and synthesizing photorealistic images beyond the original POLAR collection. Likewise, the obj assets can be integrated into simulation environments to facilitate realistic rover operations in a digital twin of a POLAR scenario. POLAR3D is publicly available to aid perception algorithm development, camera simulation efforts, and lunar simulation exercises.POLAR3D is publicly available at https://github.com/uwsbel/POLAR-digital.

Zero-Shot Policy Transferability for the Control of a Scale Autonomous Vehicle

We report on a study that employs an in-house developed simulation infrastructure to accomplish zero shot policy transferability for a control policy associated with a scale autonomous vehicle. We focus on implementing policies that require no real world data to be trained (Zero-Shot Transfer), and are developed in-house as opposed to being validated by previous works. We do this by implementing a Neural Network (NN) controller that is trained only on a family of circular reference trajectories. The sensors used are RTK-GPS and IMU, the latter for providing heading. The NN controller is trained using either a human driver (via human in the loop simulation), or a Model Predictive Control (MPC) strategy. We demonstrate these two approaches in conjunction with two operation scenarios: the vehicle follows a waypoint-defined trajectory at constant speed; and the vehicle follows a speed profile that changes along the vehicle's waypoint-defined trajectory. The primary contribution of this work is the demonstration of Zero-Shot Transfer in conjunction with a novel feed-forward NN controller trained using a general purpose, in-house developed simulation platform.

Using a Bayesian-Inference Approach to Calibrating Models for Simulation in Robotics

In robotics, simulation has the potential to reduce design time and costs, and lead to a more robust engineered solution and a safer development process. However, the use of simulators is predicated on the availability of good models. This contribution is concerned with improving the quality of these models via calibration, which is cast herein in a Bayesian framework. First, we discuss the Bayesian machinery involved in model calibration. Then, we demonstrate it in one example: calibration of a vehicle dynamics model that has low degree of freedom count and can be used for state estimation, model predictive control, or path planning. A high fidelity simulator is used to emulate the ``experiments'' and generate the data for the calibration. The merit of this work is not tied to a new Bayesian methodology for calibration, but to the demonstration of how the Bayesian machinery can establish connections among models in computational dynamics, even when the data in use is noisy. The software used to generate the results reported herein is available in a public repository for unfettered use and distribution.

Using simulation to design an MPC policy for field navigation using GPS sensing

Modeling a robust control system with a precise GPS-based state estimation capability in simulation can be useful in field navigation applications as it allows for testing and validation in a controlled environment. This testing process would enable navigation systems to be developed and optimized in simulation with direct transferability to real-world scenarios. The multi-physics simulation engine Chrono allows for the creation of scenarios that may be difficult or dangerous to replicate in the field, such as extreme weather or terrain conditions. Autonomy Research Testbed (ART), a specialized robotics algorithm testbed, is operated in conjunction with Chrono to develop an MPC control policy as well as an EKF state estimator. This platform enables users to easily integrate custom algorithms in the autonomy stack. This model is initially developed and used in simulation and then tested on a twin vehicle model in reality, to demonstrate the transferability between simulation and reality (also known as Sim2Real).

Camera simulation for robot simulation: how important are various camera model components?

Modeling cameras for the simulation of autonomous robotics is critical for generating synthetic images with appropriate realism to effectively evaluate a perception algorithm in simulation. In many cases though, simulated images are produced by traditional rendering techniques that exclude or superficially handle processing steps and aspects encountered in the actual camera pipeline. The purpose of this contribution is to quantify the degree to which the exclusion from the camera model of various image generation steps or aspects affect the sim-to-real gap in robotics. We investigate what happens if one ignores aspects tied to processes from within the physical camera, e.g., lens distortion, noise, and signal processing; scene effects, e.g., lighting and reflection; and rendering quality. The results of the study demonstrate, quantitatively, that large-scale changes to color, scene, and location have far greater impact than model aspects concerned with local, feature-level artifacts. Moreover, we show that these scene-level aspects can stem from lens distortion and signal processing, particularly when considering white-balance and auto-exposure modeling.

ART/ATK: A research platform for assessing and mitigating the sim-to-real gap in robotics and autonomous vehicle engineering

We discuss a platform that has both software and hardware components, and whose purpose is to support research into characterizing and mitigating the sim-to-real gap in robotics and vehicle autonomy engineering. The software is operating-system independent and has three main components: a simulation engine called Chrono, which supports high-fidelity vehicle and sensor simulation; an autonomy stack for algorithm design and testing; and a development environment that supports visualization and hardware-in-the-loop experimentation. The accompanying hardware platform is a 1/6th scale vehicle augmented with reconfigurable mountings for computing, sensing, and tracking. Since this vehicle platform has a digital twin within the simulation environment, one can test the same autonomy perception, state estimation, or controls algorithms, as well as the processors they run on, in both simulation and reality. A demonstration is provided to show the utilization of this platform for autonomy research. Future work will concentrate on augmenting ART/ATK with support for a full-sized Chevy Bolt EUV, which will be made available to this group in the immediate future.

Evaluating a GAN for enhancing camera simulation for robotics

Given the versatility of generative adversarial networks (GANs), we seek to understand the benefits gained from using an existing GAN to enhance simulated images and reduce the sim-to-real gap. We conduct an analysis in the context of simulating robot performance and image-based perception. Specifically, we quantify the GAN's ability to reduce the sim-to-real difference in image perception in robotics. Using semantic segmentation, we analyze the sim-to-real difference in training and testing, using nominal and enhanced simulation of a city environment. As a secondary application, we consider use of the GAN in enhancing an indoor environment. For this application, object detection is used to analyze the enhancement in training and testing. The results presented quantify the reduction in the sim-to-real gap when using the GAN, and illustrate the benefits of its use.

A performance contextualization approach to validating camera models for robot simulation

The focus of this contribution is on camera simulation as it comes into play in simulating autonomous robots for their virtual prototyping. We propose a camera model validation methodology based on the performance of a perception algorithm and the context in which the performance is measured. This approach is different than traditional validation of synthetic images, which is often done at a pixel or feature level, and tends to require matching pairs of synthetic and real images. Due to the high cost and constraints of acquiring paired images, the proposed approach is based on datasets that are not necessarily paired. Within a real and a simulated dataset, A and B, respectively, we find subsets Ac and Bc of similar content and judge, statistically, the perception algorithm's response to these similar subsets. This validation approach obtains a statistical measure of performance similarity, as well as a measure of similarity between the content of A and B. The methodology is demonstrated using images generated with Chrono::Sensor and a scaled autonomous vehicle, using an object detector as the perception algorithm. The results demonstrate the ability to quantify (i) differences between simulated and real data; (ii) the propensity of training methods to mitigate the sim-to-real gap; and (iii) the context overlap between two datasets.