Both transduction and rejection have emerged as important techniques for defending against adversarial perturbations. A recent work by Tram\`er showed that, in the rejection-only case (no transduction), a strong rejection-solution can be turned into a strong (but computationally inefficient) non-rejection solution. This detector-to-classifier reduction has been mostly applied to give evidence that certain claims of strong selective-model solutions are susceptible, leaving the benefits of rejection unclear. On the other hand, a recent work by Goldwasser et al. showed that rejection combined with transduction can give provable guarantees (for certain problems) that cannot be achieved otherwise. Nevertheless, under recent strong adversarial attacks (GMSA, which has been shown to be much more effective than AutoAttack against transduction), Goldwasser et al.'s work was shown to have low performance in a practical deep-learning setting. In this paper, we take a step towards realizing the promise of transduction+rejection in more realistic scenarios. Theoretically, we show that a novel application of Tram\`er's classifier-to-detector technique in the transductive setting can give significantly improved sample-complexity for robust generalization. While our theoretical construction is computationally inefficient, it guides us to identify an efficient transductive algorithm to learn a selective model. Extensive experiments using state of the art attacks (AutoAttack, GMSA) show that our solutions provide significantly better robust accuracy.
Data corruption, systematic or adversarial, may skew statistical estimation severely. Recent work provides computationally efficient estimators that nearly match the information-theoretic optimal statistic. Yet the corruption model they consider measures sample-level corruption and is not fine-grained enough for many real-world applications. In this paper, we propose a coordinate-level metric of distribution shift over high-dimensional settings with n coordinates. We introduce and analyze robust mean estimation techniques against an adversary who may hide individual coordinates of samples while being bounded by that metric. We show that for structured distribution settings, methods that leverage structure to fill in missing entries before mean estimation can improve the estimation accuracy by a factor of approximately n compared to structure-agnostic methods. We also leverage recent progress in matrix completion to obtain estimators for recovering the true mean of the samples in settings of unknown structure. We demonstrate with real-world data that our methods can capture the dependencies across attributes and provide accurate mean estimation even in high-magnitude corruption settings.