Interpretability and effectiveness are two essential and indispensable requirements for adopting machine learning methods in reality. In this paper, we propose a knowledge distillation based decision trees extension, dubbed rectified decision trees (ReDT), to explore the possibility of fulfilling those requirements simultaneously. Specifically, we extend the splitting criteria and the ending condition of the standard decision trees, which allows training with soft labels while preserving the deterministic splitting paths. We then train the ReDT based on the soft label distilled from a well-trained teacher model through a novel jackknife-based method. Accordingly, ReDT preserves the excellent interpretable nature of the decision trees while having a relatively good performance. The effectiveness of adopting soft labels instead of hard ones is also analyzed empirically and theoretically. Surprisingly, experiments indicate that the introduction of soft labels also reduces the model size compared with the standard decision trees from the aspect of the total nodes and rules, which is an unexpected gift from the `dark knowledge' distilled from the teacher model.