Purpose: Ultrasound (US) imaging, while advantageous for its radiation-free nature, is challenging to interpret due to only partially visible organs and a lack of complete 3D information. While performing US-based diagnosis or investigation, medical professionals therefore create a mental map of the 3D anatomy. In this work, we aim to replicate this process and enhance the visual representation of anatomical structures. Methods: We introduce a point-cloud-based probabilistic DL method to complete occluded anatomical structures through 3D shape completion and choose US-based spine examinations as our application. To enable training, we generate synthetic 3D representations of partially occluded spinal views by mimicking US physics and accounting for inherent artifacts. Results: The proposed model performs consistently on synthetic and patient data, with mean and median differences of 2.02 and 0.03 in CD, respectively. Our ablation study demonstrates the importance of US physics-based data generation, reflected in the large mean and median difference of 11.8 CD and 9.55 CD, respectively. Additionally, we demonstrate that anatomic landmarks, such as the spinous process (with reconstruction CD of 4.73) and the facet joints (mean distance to GT of 4.96mm) are preserved in the 3D completion. Conclusion: Our work establishes the feasibility of 3D shape completion for lumbar vertebrae, ensuring the preservation of level-wise characteristics and successful generalization from synthetic to real data. The incorporation of US physics contributes to more accurate patient data completions. Notably, our method preserves essential anatomic landmarks and reconstructs crucial injections sites at their correct locations. The generated data and source code will be made publicly available (https://github.com/miruna20/Shape-Completion-in-the-Dark).