Providing natural language instructions in prompts is a useful new paradigm for improving task performance of large language models in a zero-shot setting. Recent work has aimed to improve such prompts via manual rewriting or gradient-based tuning. However, manual rewriting is time-consuming and requires subjective interpretation, while gradient-based tuning can be extremely computationally demanding for large models and requires full access to model weights, which may not be available for API-based models. In this work, we introduce Gradient-free Instructional Prompt Search (GrIPS), a gradient-free, edit-based search approach for improving task instructions for large language models. GrIPS takes in instructions designed for humans and automatically returns an improved, edited prompt, while allowing for API-based tuning. The instructions in our search are iteratively edited using four operations (delete, add, swap, paraphrase) on text at the phrase-level. With InstructGPT models, GrIPS improves the average task performance by up to 4.30 percentage points on eight classification tasks from the Natural-Instructions dataset. We see improvements for both instruction-only prompts and for k-shot example+instruction prompts. Notably, GrIPS outperforms manual rewriting following the guidelines in Mishra et al. (2022) and also outperforms purely example-based prompts while controlling for the available compute and data budget. Lastly, we provide qualitative analysis of the edited instructions across several scales of GPT models. Our code is available at: https://github.com/archiki/GrIPS