CaTE Data Curation for Trustworthy AI

This report provides practical guidance to teams designing or developing AI-enabled systems for how to promote trustworthiness during the data curation phase of development. In this report, the authors first define data, the data curation phase, and trustworthiness. We then describe a series of steps that the development team, especially data scientists, can take to build a trustworthy AI-enabled system. We enumerate the sequence of core steps and trace parallel paths where alternatives exist. The descriptions of these steps include strengths, weaknesses, preconditions, outcomes, and relevant open-source software tool implementations. In total, this report is a synthesis of data curation tools and approaches from relevant academic literature, and our goal is to equip readers with a diverse yet coherent set of practices for improving AI trustworthiness.

Multiaccuracy and Multicalibration via Proxy Groups

As the use of predictive machine learning algorithms increases in high-stakes decision-making, it is imperative that these algorithms are fair across sensitive groups. Unfortunately, measuring and enforcing fairness in real-world applications can be challenging due to missing or incomplete sensitive group data. Proxy-sensitive attributes have been proposed as a practical and effective solution in these settings, but only for parity-based fairness notions. Knowing how to evaluate and control for fairness with missing sensitive group data for newer and more flexible frameworks, such as multiaccuracy and multicalibration, remains unexplored. In this work, we address this gap by demonstrating that in the absence of sensitive group data, proxy-sensitive attributes can provably be used to derive actionable upper bounds on the true multiaccuracy and multicalibration, providing insights into a model's potential worst-case fairness violations. Additionally, we show that adjusting models to satisfy multiaccuracy and multicalibration across proxy-sensitive attributes can significantly mitigate these violations for the true, but unknown, sensitive groups. Through several experiments on real-world datasets, we illustrate that approximate multiaccuracy and multicalibration can be achieved even when sensitive group information is incomplete or unavailable.