Generalization Properties of Decision Trees on Real-valued and Categorical Features

We revisit binary decision trees from the perspective of partitions of the data. We introduce the notion of partitioning function, and we relate it to the growth function and to the VC dimension. We consider three types of features: real-valued, categorical ordinal and categorical nominal, with different split rules for each. For each feature type, we upper bound the partitioning function of the class of decision stumps before extending the bounds to the class of general decision tree (of any fixed structure) using a recursive approach. Using these new results, we are able to find the exact VC dimension of decision stumps on examples of $\ell$ real-valued features, which is given by the largest integer $d$ such that $2\ell \ge \binom{d}{\lfloor\frac{d}{2}\rfloor}$. Furthermore, we show that the VC dimension of a binary tree structure with $L_T$ leaves on examples of $\ell$ real-valued features is in $O(L_T \log(L_T\ell))$. Finally, we elaborate a pruning algorithm based on these results that performs better than the cost-complexity and reduced-error pruning algorithms on a number of data sets, with the advantage that no cross-validation is required.

Improving Generalization Bounds for VC Classes Using the Hypergeometric Tail Inversion

We significantly improve the generalization bounds for VC classes by using two main ideas. First, we consider the hypergeometric tail inversion to obtain a very tight non-uniform distribution-independent risk upper bound for VC classes. Second, we optimize the ghost sample trick to obtain a further non-negligible gain. These improvements are then used to derive a relative deviation bound, a multiclass margin bound, as well as a lower bound. Numerical comparisons show that the new bound is nearly never vacuous, and is tighter than other VC bounds for all reasonable data set sizes.

Decision trees as partitioning machines to characterize their generalization properties

Decision trees are popular machine learning models that are simple to build and easy to interpret. Even though algorithms to learn decision trees date back to almost 50 years, key properties affecting their generalization error are still weakly bounded. Hence, we revisit binary decision trees on real-valued features from the perspective of partitions of the data. We introduce the notion of partitioning function, and we relate it to the growth function and to the VC dimension. Using this new concept, we are able to find the exact VC dimension of decision stumps, which is given by the largest integer $d$ such that $2\ell \ge \binom{d}{\left\lfloor\frac{d}{2}\right\rfloor}$, where $\ell$ is the number of real-valued features. We provide a recursive expression to bound the partitioning functions, resulting in a upper bound on the growth function of any decision tree structure. This allows us to show that the VC dimension of a binary tree structure with $N$ internal nodes is of order $N \log(N\ell)$. Finally, we elaborate a pruning algorithm based on these results that performs better than the CART algorithm on a number of datasets, with the advantage that no cross-validation is required.