Affine image registration is a cornerstone of medical-image processing and analysis. While classical algorithms can achieve excellent accuracy, they solve a time-consuming optimization for every new image pair. Deep-learning (DL) methods learn a function that maps an image pair to an output transform. Evaluating the functions is fast, but capturing large transforms can be challenging, and networks tend to struggle if a test-image characteristic shifts from the training domain, such as the contrast or resolution. A majority of affine methods are also agnostic to the anatomy the user wishes to align; the registration will be inaccurate if algorithms consider all structures in the image. We address these shortcomings with a fast, robust, and easy-to-use DL tool for affine and deformable registration of any brain image without preprocessing, right off the MRI scanner. First, we rigorously analyze how competing architectures learn affine transforms across a diverse set of neuroimaging data, aiming to truly capture the behavior of methods in the real world. Second, we leverage a recent strategy to train networks with wildly varying images synthesized from label maps, yielding robust performance across acquisition specifics. Third, we optimize the spatial overlap of select anatomical labels, which enables networks to distinguish between anatomy of interest and irrelevant structures, removing the need for preprocessing that excludes content that would otherwise reduce the accuracy of anatomy-specific registration. We combine the affine model with prior work on deformable registration and test brain-specific registration across a landscape of MRI protocols unseen at training, demonstrating consistent and improved accuracy compared to existing tools. We distribute our code and tool at https://w3id.org/synthmorph, providing a single complete end-to-end solution for registration of brain MRI.