Federated learning (FL) is an emerging machine learning (ML) paradigm that enables heterogeneous edge devices to collaboratively train ML models without revealing their raw data to a logically centralized server. Heterogeneity across participants is a fundamental challenge in FL, both in terms of non-independent and identically distributed (Non-IID) data distributions and variations in device capabilities. Many existing works present point solutions to address issues like slow convergence, low final accuracy, and bias in FL, all stemming from the client heterogeneity. We observe that, in a large population, there exist groups of clients with statistically similar data distributions (cohorts). In this paper, we propose Auxo to gradually identify cohorts among large-scale, low-participation, and resource-constrained FL populations. Auxo then adaptively determines how to train cohort-specific models in order to achieve better model performance and ensure resource efficiency. By identifying cohorts with smaller heterogeneity and performing efficient cohort-based training, our extensive evaluations show that Auxo substantially boosts the state-of-the-art solutions in terms of final accuracy, convergence time, and model bias.