Long-range transformer models have achieved encouraging results on long-context question answering (QA) tasks. Such tasks often require reasoning over a long document, and they benefit from identifying a set of evidence spans (e.g., sentences) that provide supporting evidence for addressing the question. In this work, we propose a novel method for equipping long-range transformers with an additional sequence-level objective for better identification of supporting evidence spans. We achieve this by proposing an additional contrastive supervision signal in finetuning, where the model is encouraged to explicitly discriminate supporting evidence sentences from negative ones by maximizing the question-evidence similarity. The proposed additional loss exhibits consistent improvements on three different strong long-context transformer models, across two challenging question answering benchmarks - HotpotQA and QAsper.