An unsupervised, lightweight and high-performance single object tracker, called UHP-SOT, was proposed by Zhou et al. recently. As an extension, we present an enhanced version and name it UHP-SOT++ in this work. Built upon the foundation of the discriminative-correlation-filters-based (DCF-based) tracker, two new ingredients are introduced in UHP-SOT and UHP-SOT++: 1) background motion modeling and 2) object box trajectory modeling. The main difference between UHP-SOT and UHP-SOT++ is the fusion strategy of proposals from three models (i.e., DCF, background motion and object box trajectory models). An improved fusion strategy is adopted by UHP-SOT++ for more robust tracking performance against large-scale tracking datasets. Our second contribution lies in an extensive evaluation of the performance of state-of-the-art supervised and unsupervised methods by testing them on four SOT benchmark datasets - OTB2015, TC128, UAV123 and LaSOT. Experiments show that UHP-SOT++ outperforms all previous unsupervised methods and several deep-learning (DL) methods in tracking accuracy. Since UHP-SOT++ has extremely small model size, high tracking performance, and low computational complexity (operating at a rate of 20 FPS on an i5 CPU even without code optimization), it is an ideal solution in real-time object tracking on resource-limited platforms. Based on the experimental results, we compare pros and cons of supervised and unsupervised trackers and provide a new perspective to understand the performance gap between supervised and unsupervised methods, which is the third contribution of this work.