Automatic Failure Recovery for End-User Programs on Service Mobile Robots

For service mobile robots to be most effective, it must be possible for non-experts and even end-users to program them to do new tasks. Regardless of the programming method (e.g., by demonstration or traditional programming), robot task programs are challenging to write, because they rely on multiple actions to succeed, including human-robot interactions. Unfortunately, interactions are prone to fail, because a human may perform the wrong action (e.g., if the robot's request is not clear). Moreover, when the robot cannot directly observe the human action, it may not detect the failure until several steps after it occurs. Therefore, writing fault-tolerant robot tasks is beyond the ability of non-experts. This paper presents a principled approach to detect and recover from a broad class of failures that occur in end-user programs on service mobile robots. We present a two-tiered Robot Task Programming Language (RTPL): 1) an expert roboticist uses a specification language to write a probabilistic model of the robot's actions and interactions, and 2) a non-expert then writes an ordinary sequential program for a particular task. The RTPL runtime system executes the task program sequentially, while using the probabilistic model to build a Bayesian network that tracks possible, unobserved failures. If an error is observed, RTPL uses Bayesian inference to find the likely root cause of the error, and then attempts to re-execute a portion of the program for recovery. Our empirical results show that RTPL 1) allows complex tasks to be written concisely, 2) correctly identifies the root cause of failure, and 3) allows multiple tasks to recover from a variety of errors, without task-specific error-recovery code.