Communication-efficient SGD algorithms, which allow nodes to perform local updates and perform infrequent synchronization between them, are highly effective in improving the speed and scalability of distributed SGD. However, a rigorous convergence analysis and comparative study of different communication-reduction strategies remains a largely open problem. This paper presents a new framework called Cooperative SGD that subsumes existing communication-efficient SGD algorithms such as periodic-averaging, elastic-averaging and decentralized SGD. By analyzing Cooperative SGD, we provide novel convergence guarantees for existing algorithms. Moreover this framework enables us to design new communication-efficient SGD algorithms that strike the best balance between reducing communication overhead and achieving fast error convergence.