Low-rank matrix completion (MC) has achieved great success in many real-world data applications. A latent feature model formulation is usually employed and, to improve prediction performance, the similarities between latent variables can be exploited by pairwise learning, e.g., the graph regularized matrix factorization (GRMF) method. However, existing GRMF approaches often use a squared L2 norm to measure the pairwise difference, which may be overly influenced by dissimilar pairs and lead to inferior prediction. To fully empower pairwise learning for matrix completion, we propose a general optimization framework that allows a rich class of (non-)convex pairwise penalty functions. A new and efficient algorithm is further developed to uniformly solve the optimization problem, with a theoretical convergence guarantee. In an important situation where the latent variables form a small number of subgroups, its statistical guarantee is also fully characterized. In particular, we theoretically characterize the complexity-regularized maximum likelihood estimator, as a special case of our framework. It has a better error bound when compared to the standard trace-norm regularized matrix completion. We conduct extensive experiments on both synthetic and real datasets to demonstrate the superior performance of this general framework.