Adaptive Privacy Composition for Accuracy-first Mechanisms

In many practical applications of differential privacy, practitioners seek to provide the best privacy guarantees subject to a target level of accuracy. A recent line of work by \cite{LigettNeRoWaWu17, WhitehouseWuRaRo22} has developed such accuracy-first mechanisms by leveraging the idea of \emph{noise reduction} that adds correlated noise to the sufficient statistic in a private computation and produces a sequence of increasingly accurate answers. A major advantage of noise reduction mechanisms is that the analysts only pay the privacy cost of the least noisy or most accurate answer released. Despite this appealing property in isolation, there has not been a systematic study on how to use them in conjunction with other differentially private mechanisms. A fundamental challenge is that the privacy guarantee for noise reduction mechanisms is (necessarily) formulated as \emph{ex-post privacy} that bounds the privacy loss as a function of the released outcome. Furthermore, there has yet to be any study on how ex-post private mechanisms compose, which allows us to track the accumulated privacy over several mechanisms. We develop privacy filters \citep{RogersRoUlVa16, FeldmanZr21, WhitehouseRaRoWu22} that allow an analyst to adaptively switch between differentially private and ex-post private mechanisms subject to an overall privacy guarantee.