Analyzing Adversarial Inputs in Deep Reinforcement Learning

In recent years, Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) has become a popular paradigm in machine learning due to its successful applications to real-world and complex systems. However, even the state-of-the-art DRL models have been shown to suffer from reliability concerns -- for example, their susceptibility to adversarial inputs, i.e., small and abundant input perturbations that can fool the models into making unpredictable and potentially dangerous decisions. This drawback limits the deployment of DRL systems in safety-critical contexts, where even a small error cannot be tolerated. In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis of the characterization of adversarial inputs, through the lens of formal verification. Specifically, we introduce a novel metric, the Adversarial Rate, to classify models based on their susceptibility to such perturbations, and present a set of tools and algorithms for its computation. Our analysis empirically demonstrates how adversarial inputs can affect the safety of a given DRL system with respect to such perturbations. Moreover, we analyze the behavior of these configurations to suggest several useful practices and guidelines to help mitigate the vulnerability of trained DRL networks.

Marabou 2.0: A Versatile Formal Analyzer of Neural Networks

This paper serves as a comprehensive system description of version 2.0 of the Marabou framework for formal analysis of neural networks. We discuss the tool's architectural design and highlight the major features and components introduced since its initial release.

Formally Explaining Neural Networks within Reactive Systems

Deep neural networks (DNNs) are increasingly being used as controllers in reactive systems. However, DNNs are highly opaque, which renders it difficult to explain and justify their actions. To mitigate this issue, there has been a surge of interest in explainable AI (XAI) techniques, capable of pinpointing the input features that caused the DNN to act as it did. Existing XAI techniques typically face two limitations: (i) they are heuristic, and do not provide formal guarantees that the explanations are correct; and (ii) they often apply to ``one-shot'' systems, where the DNN is invoked independently of past invocations, as opposed to reactive systems. Here, we begin bridging this gap, and propose a formal DNN-verification-based XAI technique for reasoning about multi-step, reactive systems. We suggest methods for efficiently calculating succinct explanations, by exploiting the system's transition constraints in order to curtail the search space explored by the underlying verifier. We evaluate our approach on two popular benchmarks from the domain of automated navigation; and observe that our methods allow the efficient computation of minimal and minimum explanations, significantly outperforming the state of the art. We also demonstrate that our methods produce formal explanations that are more reliable than competing, non-verification-based XAI techniques.

Verifying Generalization in Deep Learning

Deep neural networks (DNNs) are the workhorses of deep learning, which constitutes the state of the art in numerous application domains. However, DNN-based decision rules are notoriously prone to poor generalization, i.e., may prove inadequate on inputs not encountered during training. This limitation poses a significant obstacle to employing deep learning for mission-critical tasks, and also in real-world environments that exhibit high variability. We propose a novel, verification-driven methodology for identifying DNN-based decision rules that generalize well to new input domains. Our approach quantifies generalization to an input domain by the extent to which decisions reached by independently trained DNNs are in agreement for inputs in this domain. We show how, by harnessing the power of DNN verification, our approach can be efficiently and effectively realized. We evaluate our verification-based approach on three deep reinforcement learning (DRL) benchmarks, including a system for real-world Internet congestion control. Our results establish the usefulness of our approach, and, in particular, its superiority over gradient-based methods. More broadly, our work puts forth a novel objective for formal verification, with the potential for mitigating the risks associated with deploying DNN-based systems in the wild.

veriFIRE: Verifying an Industrial, Learning-Based Wildfire Detection System

In this short paper, we present our ongoing work on the veriFIRE project -- a collaboration between industry and academia, aimed at using verification for increasing the reliability of a real-world, safety-critical system. The system we target is an airborne platform for wildfire detection, which incorporates two deep neural networks. We describe the system and its properties of interest, and discuss our attempts to verify the system's consistency, i.e., its ability to continue and correctly classify a given input, even if the wildfire it describes increases in intensity. We regard this work as a step towards the incorporation of academic-oriented verification tools into real-world systems of interest.

Constrained Reinforcement Learning for Robotics via Scenario-Based Programming

Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) has achieved groundbreaking successes in a wide variety of robotic applications. A natural consequence is the adoption of this paradigm for safety-critical tasks, where human safety and expensive hardware can be involved. In this context, it is crucial to optimize the performance of DRL-based agents while providing guarantees about their behavior. This paper presents a novel technique for incorporating domain-expert knowledge into a constrained DRL training loop. Our technique exploits the scenario-based programming paradigm, which is designed to allow specifying such knowledge in a simple and intuitive way. We validated our method on the popular robotic mapless navigation problem, in simulation, and on the actual platform. Our experiments demonstrate that using our approach to leverage expert knowledge dramatically improves the safety and the performance of the agent.

Verifying Learning-Based Robotic Navigation Systems

Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) has become a dominant deep-learning paradigm for various tasks in which complex policies are learned within reactive systems. In parallel, there has recently been significant research on verifying deep neural networks. However, to date, there has been little work demonstrating the use of modern verification tools on real, DRL-controlled systems. In this case-study paper, we attempt to begin bridging this gap, and focus on the important task of mapless robotic navigation -- a classic robotics problem, in which a robot, usually controlled by a DRL agent, needs to efficiently and safely navigate through an unknown arena towards a desired target. We demonstrate how modern verification engines can be used for effective model selection, i.e., the process of selecting the best available policy for the robot in question from a pool of candidate policies. Specifically, we use verification to detect and rule out policies that may demonstrate suboptimal behavior, such as collisions and infinite loops. We also apply verification to identify models with overly conservative behavior, thus allowing users to choose superior policies that are better at finding an optimal, shorter path to a target. To validate our work, we conducted extensive experiments on an actual robot, and confirmed that the suboptimal policies detected by our method were indeed flawed. We also compared our verification-driven approach to state-of-the-art gradient attacks, and our results demonstrate that gradient-based methods are inadequate in this setting. Our work is the first to demonstrate the use of DNN verification backends for recognizing suboptimal DRL policies in real-world robots, and for filtering out unwanted policies. We believe that the methods presented in this work can be applied to a large range of application domains that incorporate deep-learning-based agents.

Scenario-Assisted Deep Reinforcement Learning

Deep reinforcement learning has proven remarkably useful in training agents from unstructured data. However, the opacity of the produced agents makes it difficult to ensure that they adhere to various requirements posed by human engineers. In this work-in-progress report, we propose a technique for enhancing the reinforcement learning training process (specifically, its reward calculation), in a way that allows human engineers to directly contribute their expert knowledge, making the agent under training more likely to comply with various relevant constraints. Moreover, our proposed approach allows formulating these constraints using advanced model engineering techniques, such as scenario-based modeling. This mix of black-box learning-based tools with classical modeling approaches could produce systems that are effective and efficient, but are also more transparent and maintainable. We evaluated our technique using a case-study from the domain of internet congestion control, obtaining promising results.

Verification-Aided Deep Ensemble Selection

Deep neural networks (DNNs) have become the technology of choice for realizing a variety of complex tasks. However, as highlighted by many recent studies, even an imperceptible perturbation to a correctly classified input can lead to misclassification by a DNN. This renders DNNs vulnerable to strategic input manipulations by attackers, and also prone to oversensitivity to environmental noise. To mitigate this phenomenon, practitioners apply joint classification by an ensemble of DNNs. By aggregating the classification outputs of different individual DNNs for the same input, ensemble-based classification reduces the risk of misclassifications due to the specific realization of the stochastic training process of any single DNN. However, the effectiveness of a DNN ensemble is highly dependent on its members not simultaneously erring on many different inputs. In this case study, we harness recent advances in DNN verification to devise a methodology for identifying ensemble compositions that are less prone to simultaneous errors, even when the input is adversarially perturbed -- resulting in more robustly-accurate ensemble-based classification. Our proposed framework uses a DNN verifier as a backend, and includes heuristics that help reduce the high complexity of directly verifying ensembles. More broadly, our work puts forth a novel universal objective for formal verification that can potentially improve the robustness of real-world, deep-learning-based systems across a variety of application domains.