Reconstructing the cortex from longitudinal MRI is indispensable for analyzing morphological changes in the human brain. Despite the recent disruption of cortical surface reconstruction with deep learning, challenges arising from longitudinal data are still persistent. Especially the lack of strong spatiotemporal point correspondence hinders downstream analyses due to the introduced noise. To address this issue, we present V2C-Long, the first dedicated deep learning-based cortex reconstruction method for longitudinal MRI. In contrast to existing methods, V2C-Long surfaces are directly comparable in a cross-sectional and longitudinal manner. We establish strong inherent spatiotemporal correspondences via a novel composition of two deep mesh deformation networks and fast aggregation of feature-enhanced within-subject templates. The results on internal and external test data demonstrate that V2C-Long yields cortical surfaces with improved accuracy and consistency compared to previous methods. Finally, this improvement manifests in higher sensitivity to regional cortical atrophy in Alzheimer's disease.