The current definition of a Bayesian credible set cannot, in general, achieve an arbitrarily preassigned credible level. This drawback is particularly acute for classification problems, where there are only a finite number of achievable credible levels. As a result, there is as of today no general way to construct an exact credible set for classification. In this paper, we introduce a generalized credible set that can achieve any preassigned credible level. The key insight is a simple connection between the Bayesian highest posterior density credible set and the Neyman--Pearson lemma, which, as far as we know, hasn't been noticed before. Using this connection, we introduce a randomized decision rule to fill the gaps among the discrete credible levels. Accompanying this methodology, we also develop the Steering Wheel Plot to represent the credible set, which is useful in visualizing the uncertainty in classification. By developing the exact credible set for discrete parameters, we make the theory of Bayesian inference more complete.