Given the success of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) for structure-aware machine learning, numerous studies have explored their application to text classification, as an alternative to traditional feature representation models. However, most studies considered just a specific domain and validated on data with particular characteristics. This work presents an extensive empirical investigation of graph-based text representation methods proposed for text classification, identifying practical implications and open challenges in the field. We compare several GNN architectures as well as BERT across five datasets, encompassing short and also long documents. The results show that: i) graph performance is highly related to the textual input features and domain, ii) despite its outstanding performance, BERT has difficulties converging when dealing with short texts, iii) graph methods are particularly beneficial for longer documents.