In Multi-Task Learning, tasks may compete and limit the performance achieved on each other rather than guiding the optimization trajectory to a common solution, superior to its single-task counterparts. There is often not a single solution that is optimal for all tasks, leading practitioners to balance tradeoffs between tasks' performance, and to resort to optimality in the Pareto sense. Current Multi-Task Learning methodologies either completely neglect this aspect of functional diversity, and produce one solution in the Pareto Front predefined by their optimization schemes, or produce diverse but discrete solutions, each requiring a separate training run. In this paper, we conjecture that there exist Pareto Subspaces, i.e., weight subspaces where multiple optimal functional solutions lie. We propose Pareto Manifold Learning, an ensembling method in weight space that is able to discover such a parameterization and produces a continuous Pareto Front in a single training run, allowing practitioners to modulate the performance on each task during inference on the fly. We validate the proposed method on a diverse set of multi-task learning benchmarks, ranging from image classification to tabular datasets and scene understanding, and show that Pareto Manifold Learning outperforms state-of-the-art algorithms.