Evolution gave rise to human and animal intelligence here on Earth. We argue that the path to developing artificial human-like-intelligence will pass through mimicking the evolutionary process in a nature-like simulation. In Nature, there are two processes driving the development of the brain: evolution and learning. Evolution acts slowly, across generations, and amongst other things, it defines what agents learn by changing their internal reward function. Learning acts fast, across one's lifetime, and it quickly updates agents' policy to maximise pleasure and minimise pain. The reward function is slowly aligned with the fitness function by evolution, however, as agents evolve the environment and its fitness function also change, increasing the misalignment between reward and fitness. It is extremely computationally expensive to replicate these two processes in simulation. This work proposes Evolution via Evolutionary Reward (EvER) that allows learning to single-handedly drive the search for policies with increasingly evolutionary fitness by ensuring the alignment of the reward function with the fitness function. In this search, EvER makes use of the whole state-action trajectories that agents go through their lifetime. In contrast, current evolutionary algorithms discard this information and consequently limit their potential efficiency at tackling sequential decision problems. We test our algorithm in two simple bio-inspired environments and show its superiority at generating more capable agents at surviving and reproducing their genes when compared with a state-of-the-art evolutionary algorithm.