In reinforcement learning, the discount factor $\gamma$ controls the agent's effective planning horizon. Traditionally, this parameter was considered part of the MDP; however, as deep reinforcement learning algorithms tend to become unstable when the effective planning horizon is long, recent works refer to $\gamma$ as a hyper-parameter. In this work, we focus on the finite-horizon setting and introduce \emph{reward tweaking}. Reward tweaking learns a surrogate reward function $\tilde r$ for the discounted setting, which induces an optimal (undiscounted) return in the original finite-horizon task. Theoretically, we show that there exists a surrogate reward which leads to optimality in the original task and discuss the robustness of our approach. Additionally, we perform experiments in a high-dimensional continuous control task and show that reward tweaking guides the agent towards better long-horizon returns when it plans for short horizons using the tweaked reward.