Selecting hyperparameters for unsupervised learning problems is difficult in general due to the lack of ground truth for validation. However, this issue is prevalent in machine learning, especially in clustering problems with examples including the Lagrange multipliers of penalty terms in semidefinite programming (SDP) relaxations and the bandwidths used for constructing kernel similarity matrices for Spectral Clustering. Despite this, there are not many provable algorithms for tuning these hyperparameters. In this paper, we provide a unified framework with provable guarantees for the above class of problems. We demonstrate our method on two distinct models. First, we show how to tune the hyperparameters in widely used SDP algorithms for community detection in networks. In this case, our method can also be used for model selection. Second, we show the same framework works for choosing the bandwidth for the kernel similarity matrix in Spectral Clustering for subgaussian mixtures under suitable model specification. In a variety of simulation experiments, we show that our framework outperforms other widely used tuning procedures in a broad range of parameter settings.