For many machine learning problems, data is abundant and it may be prohibitive to make multiple passes through the full training set. In this context, we investigate strategies for dynamically increasing the effective sample size, when using iterative methods such as stochastic gradient descent. Our interest is motivated by the rise of variance-reduced methods, which achieve linear convergence rates that scale favorably for smaller sample sizes. Exploiting this feature, we show -- theoretically and empirically -- how to obtain significant speed-ups with a novel algorithm that reaches statistical accuracy on an $n$-sample in $2n$, instead of $n \log n$ steps.