W-kernel and essential subspace for frequencist's evaluation of Bayesian estimators

The posterior covariance matrix W defined by the log-likelihood of each observation plays important roles both in the sensitivity analysis and frequencist's evaluation of the Bayesian estimators. This study focused on the matrix W and its principal space; we term the latter as an essential subspace. First, it is shown that they appear in various statistical settings, such as the evaluation of the posterior sensitivity, assessment of the frequencist's uncertainty from posterior samples, and stochastic expansion of the loss; a key tool to treat frequencist's properties is the recently proposed Bayesian infinitesimal jackknife approximation (Giordano and Broderick (2023)). In the following part, we show that the matrix W can be interpreted as a reproducing kernel; it is named as W-kernel. Using the W-kernel, the essential subspace is expressed as a principal space given by the kernel PCA. A relation to the Fisher kernel and neural tangent kernel is established, which elucidates the connection to the classical asymptotic theory; it also leads to a sort of Bayesian-frequencist's duality. Finally, two applications, selection of a representative set of observations and dimensional reduction in the approximate bootstrap, are discussed. In the former, incomplete Cholesky decomposition is introduced as an efficient method to compute the essential subspace. In the latter, different implementations of the approximate bootstrap for posterior means are compared.

Posterior Covariance Information Criterion

We introduce an information criterion, PCIC, for predictive evaluation based on quasi-posterior distributions. It is regarded as a natural generalisation of the widely applicable information criterion (WAIC) and can be computed via a single Markov chain Monte Carlo run. PCIC is useful in a variety of predictive settings that are not well dealt with in WAIC, including weighted likelihood inference and quasi-Bayesian prediction