Verifying user attributes to provide fine-grained access control to databases is fundamental to an attribute-based authentication system. In such systems, either a single (central) authority verifies all attributes, or multiple independent authorities verify individual attributes distributedly to allow a user to access records stored on the servers. While a \emph{central} setup is more communication cost efficient, it causes privacy breach of \emph{all} user attributes to a central authority. Recently, Jafarpisheh et al. studied an information theoretic formulation of the \emph{distributed} multi-authority setup with $N$ non-colluding authorities, $N$ attributes and $K$ possible values for each attribute, called an $(N,K)$ distributed attribute-based private access control (DAPAC) system, where each server learns only one attribute value that it verifies, and remains oblivious to the remaining $N-1$ attributes. We show that off-loading a subset of attributes to a central server for verification improves the achievable rate from $\frac{1}{2K}$ in Jafarpisheh et al. to $\frac{1}{K+1}$ in this paper, thus \emph{almost doubling the rate} for relatively large $K$, while sacrificing the privacy of a few possibly non-sensitive attributes.
We consider the setup of a constrained optimization problem with two agents $E_1$ and $E_2$ who jointly wish to learn the optimal solution set while keeping their feasible sets $\mathcal{P}_1$ and $\mathcal{P}_2$ private from each other. The objective function $f$ is globally known and each feasible set is a collection of points from a global alphabet. We adopt a sequential symmetric private information retrieval (SPIR) framework where one of the agents (say $E_1$) privately checks in $\mathcal{P}_2$, the presence of candidate solutions of the problem constrained to $\mathcal{P}_1$ only, while learning no further information on $\mathcal{P}_2$ than the solution alone. Further, we extract an information theoretically private threshold PSI (ThPSI) protocol from our scheme and characterize its download cost. We show that, compared to privately acquiring the feasible set $\mathcal{P}_1\cap \mathcal{P}_2$ using an SPIR-based private set intersection (PSI) protocol, and finding the optimum, our scheme is better as it incurs less information leakage and less download cost than the former. Over all possible uniform mappings of $f$ to a fixed range of values, our scheme outperforms the former with a high probability.