Privacy Preserving Federated Learning with Convolutional Variational Bottlenecks

Gradient inversion attacks are an ubiquitous threat in federated learning as they exploit gradient leakage to reconstruct supposedly private training data. Recent work has proposed to prevent gradient leakage without loss of model utility by incorporating a PRivacy EnhanCing mODulE (PRECODE) based on variational modeling. Without further analysis, it was shown that PRECODE successfully protects against gradient inversion attacks. In this paper, we make multiple contributions. First, we investigate the effect of PRECODE on gradient inversion attacks to reveal its underlying working principle. We show that variational modeling introduces stochasticity into the gradients of PRECODE and the subsequent layers in a neural network. The stochastic gradients of these layers prevent iterative gradient inversion attacks from converging. Second, we formulate an attack that disables the privacy preserving effect of PRECODE by purposefully omitting stochastic gradients during attack optimization. To preserve the privacy preserving effect of PRECODE, our analysis reveals that variational modeling must be placed early in the network. However, early placement of PRECODE is typically not feasible due to reduced model utility and the exploding number of additional model parameters. Therefore, as a third contribution, we propose a novel privacy module -- the Convolutional Variational Bottleneck (CVB) -- that can be placed early in a neural network without suffering from these drawbacks. We conduct an extensive empirical study on three seminal model architectures and six image classification datasets. We find that all architectures are susceptible to gradient leakage attacks, which can be prevented by our proposed CVB. Compared to PRECODE, we show that our novel privacy module requires fewer trainable parameters, and thus computational and communication costs, to effectively preserve privacy.

Dropout is NOT All You Need to Prevent Gradient Leakage

Gradient inversion attacks on federated learning systems reconstruct client training data from exchanged gradient information. To defend against such attacks, a variety of defense mechanisms were proposed. However, they usually lead to an unacceptable trade-off between privacy and model utility. Recent observations suggest that dropout could mitigate gradient leakage and improve model utility if added to neural networks. Unfortunately, this phenomenon has not been systematically researched yet. In this work, we thoroughly analyze the effect of dropout on iterative gradient inversion attacks. We find that state of the art attacks are not able to reconstruct the client data due to the stochasticity induced by dropout during model training. Nonetheless, we argue that dropout does not offer reliable protection if the dropout induced stochasticity is adequately modeled during attack optimization. Consequently, we propose a novel Dropout Inversion Attack (DIA) that jointly optimizes for client data and dropout masks to approximate the stochastic client model. We conduct an extensive systematic evaluation of our attack on four seminal model architectures and three image classification datasets of increasing complexity. We find that our proposed attack bypasses the protection seemingly induced by dropout and reconstructs client data with high fidelity. Our work demonstrates that privacy inducing changes to model architectures alone cannot be assumed to reliably protect from gradient leakage and therefore should be combined with complementary defense mechanisms.

Combining Variational Modeling with Partial Gradient Perturbation to Prevent Deep Gradient Leakage

Exploiting gradient leakage to reconstruct supposedly private training data, gradient inversion attacks are an ubiquitous threat in collaborative learning of neural networks. To prevent gradient leakage without suffering from severe loss in model performance, recent work proposed a PRivacy EnhanCing mODulE (PRECODE) based on variational modeling as extension for arbitrary model architectures. In this work, we investigate the effect of PRECODE on gradient inversion attacks to reveal its underlying working principle. We show that variational modeling induces stochasticity on PRECODE's and its subsequent layers' gradients that prevents gradient attacks from convergence. By purposefully omitting those stochastic gradients during attack optimization, we formulate an attack that can disable PRECODE's privacy preserving effects. To ensure privacy preservation against such targeted attacks, we propose PRECODE with Partial Perturbation (PPP), as strategic combination of variational modeling and partial gradient perturbation. We conduct an extensive empirical study on four seminal model architectures and two image classification datasets. We find all architectures to be prone to gradient leakage, which can be prevented by PPP. In result, we show that our approach requires less gradient perturbation to effectively preserve privacy without harming model performance.

PRECODE - A Generic Model Extension to Prevent Deep Gradient Leakage

Collaborative training of neural networks leverages distributed data by exchanging gradient information between different clients. Although training data entirely resides with the clients, recent work shows that training data can be reconstructed from such exchanged gradient information. To enhance privacy, gradient perturbation techniques have been proposed. However, they come at the cost of reduced model performance, increased convergence time, or increased data demand. In this paper, we introduce PRECODE, a PRivacy EnhanCing mODulE that can be used as generic extension for arbitrary model architectures. We propose a simple yet effective realization of PRECODE using variational modeling. The stochastic sampling induced by variational modeling effectively prevents privacy leakage from gradients and in turn preserves privacy of data owners. We evaluate PRECODE using state of the art gradient inversion attacks on two different model architectures trained on three datasets. In contrast to commonly used defense mechanisms, we find that our proposed modification consistently reduces the attack success rate to 0% while having almost no negative impact on model training and final performance. As a result, PRECODE reveals a promising path towards privacy enhancing model extensions.