This research aims to improve the accuracy of complex volleyball predictions and provide more meaningful insights to coaches and players. We introduce a specialized graph encoding technique to add additional contact-by-contact volleyball context to an already available volleyball dataset without any additional data gathering. We demonstrate the potential benefits of using graph neural networks (GNNs) on this enriched dataset for three different volleyball prediction tasks: rally outcome prediction, set location prediction, and hit type prediction. We compare the performance of our graph-based models to baseline models and analyze the results to better understand the underlying relationships in a volleyball rally. Our results show that the use of GNNs with our graph encoding yields a much more advanced analysis of the data, which noticeably improves prediction results overall. We also show that these baseline tasks can be significantly improved with simple adjustments, such as removing blocked hits. Lastly, we demonstrate the importance of choosing a model architecture that will better extract the important information for a certain task. Overall, our study showcases the potential strengths and weaknesses of using graph encodings in sports data analytics and hopefully will inspire future improvements in machine learning strategies across sports and applications by using graphbased encodings.