Privacy-preserving clustering groups data points in an unsupervised manner whilst ensuring that sensitive information remains protected. Previous privacy-preserving clustering focused on identifying concentration of point clouds. In this paper, we take another path and focus on identifying appropriate separators that split a data set. We introduce the novel differentially private clustering algorithm DPM that searches for accurate data point separators in a differentially private manner. DPM addresses two key challenges for finding accurate separators: identifying separators that are large gaps between clusters instead of small gaps within a cluster and, to efficiently spend the privacy budget, prioritising separators that split the data into large subparts. Using the differentially private Exponential Mechanism, DPM randomly chooses cluster separators with provably high utility: For a data set $D$, if there is a wide low-density separator in the central $60\%$ quantile, DPM finds that separator with probability $1 - \exp(-\sqrt{|D|})$. Our experimental evaluation demonstrates that DPM achieves significant improvements in terms of the clustering metric inertia. With the inertia results of the non-private KMeans++ as a baseline, for $\varepsilon = 1$ and $\delta=10^{-5}$ DPM improves upon the difference to the baseline by up to $50\%$ for a synthetic data set and by up to $62\%$ for a real-world data set compared to a state-of-the-art clustering algorithm by Chang and Kamath.