Though second-order optimization methods are highly effective, popular approaches in machine learning such as SGD and Adam use only first-order information due to the difficulty of computing curvature in high dimensions. We present FOSI, a novel meta-algorithm that improves the performance of any first-order optimizer by efficiently incorporating second-order information during the optimization process. In each iteration, FOSI implicitly splits the function into two quadratic functions defined on orthogonal subspaces, then uses a second-order method to minimize the first, and the base optimizer to minimize the other. Our analysis of FOSI's preconditioner and effective Hessian proves that FOSI improves the condition number for a large family of optimizers. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates that FOSI improves the convergence rate and optimization time of GD, Heavy-Ball, and Adam when applied to several deep neural networks training tasks such as audio classification, transfer learning, and object classification and when applied to convex functions.