Many visualization techniques have been created to help explain the behavior of convolutional neural networks (CNNs), but they largely consist of static diagrams that convey limited information. Interactive visualizations can provide more rich insights and allow users to more easily explore a model's behavior; however, they are typically not easily reusable and are specific to a particular model. We introduce Visual Feature Search, a novel interactive visualization that is generalizable to any CNN and can easily be incorporated into a researcher's workflow. Our tool allows a user to highlight an image region and search for images from a given dataset with the most similar CNN features. It supports searching through large image datasets with an efficient cache-based search implementation. We demonstrate how our tool elucidates different aspects of model behavior by performing experiments on supervised, self-supervised, and human-edited CNNs. We also release a portable Python library and several IPython notebooks to enable researchers to easily use our tool in their own experiments. Our code can be found at https://github.com/lookingglasslab/VisualFeatureSearch.