Modeling real-world sound is a fundamental problem in the creative use of machine learning and many other fields, including human speech processing and bioacoustics. Transformer-based generative models and some prior work (e.g., DDSP) are known to produce realistic sound, although they have limited control and are hard to interpret. As an alternative, we aim to use modular synthesizers, i.e., compositional, parametric electronic musical instruments, for modeling non-music sounds. However, inferring synthesizer parameters given a target sound, i.e., the parameter inference task, is not trivial for general sounds, and past research has typically focused on musical sound. In this work, we optimize a differentiable synthesizer from TorchSynth in order to model, emulate, and creatively generate animal vocalizations. We compare an array of optimization methods, from gradient-based search to genetic algorithms, for inferring its parameters, and then demonstrate how one can control and interpret the parameters for modeling non-music sounds.