NLU systems deployed in the real world are expected to be regularly updated by retraining or finetuning the underlying neural network on new training examples accumulated over time. In our work, we focus on the multilingual setting where we would want to further finetune a multilingual model on new training data for the same NLU task on which the aforementioned model has already been trained for. We show that under certain conditions, naively updating the multilingual model can lead to losses in performance over a subset of languages although the aggregated performance metric shows an improvement. We establish this phenomenon over four tasks belonging to three task families (token-level, sentence-level and seq2seq) and find that the baseline is far from ideal for the setting at hand. We then build upon recent advances in parameter-efficient finetuning to develop novel finetuning pipelines that allow us to jointly minimize catastrophic forgetting while encouraging positive cross-lingual transfer, hence improving the spread of gains over different languages while reducing the losses incurred in this setup.