As object detectors rapidly improve, attention has expanded past image-only networks to include a range of 3D and multimodal frameworks, especially ones that incorporate LiDAR. However, due to cost, logistics, and even some safety considerations, stereo can be an appealing alternative. Towards understanding the efficacy of stereo as a replacement for monocular input or LiDAR in object detectors, we show that multimodal learning with traditional disparity algorithms can improve image-based results without increasing the number of parameters, and that learning over stereo error can impart similar 3D localization power to LiDAR in certain contexts. Furthermore, doing so also has calibration benefits with respect to image-only methods. We benchmark on the public dataset KITTI, and in doing so, reveal a few small but common algorithmic mistakes currently used in computing metrics on that set, and offer efficient, provably correct alternatives.