Modern deep neural networks have achieved remarkable progress in medical image segmentation tasks. However, it has recently been observed that they tend to produce overconfident estimates, even in situations of high uncertainty, leading to poorly calibrated and unreliable models. In this work we introduce Maximum Entropy on Erroneous Predictions (MEEP), a training strategy for segmentation networks which selectively penalizes overconfident predictions, focusing only on misclassified pixels. In particular, we design a regularization term that encourages high entropy posteriors for wrong predictions, increasing the network uncertainty in complex scenarios. Our method is agnostic to the neural architecture, does not increase model complexity and can be coupled with multiple segmentation loss functions. We benchmark the proposed strategy in two challenging medical image segmentation tasks: white matter hyperintensity lesions in magnetic resonance images (MRI) of the brain, and atrial segmentation in cardiac MRI. The experimental results demonstrate that coupling MEEP with standard segmentation losses leads to improvements not only in terms of model calibration, but also in segmentation quality.