Graph representation learning is a fast-growing field where one of the main objectives is to generate meaningful representations of graphs in lower-dimensional spaces. The learned embeddings have been successfully applied to perform various prediction tasks, such as link prediction, node classification, clustering, and visualization. The collective effort of the graph learning community has delivered hundreds of methods, but no single method excels under all evaluation metrics such as prediction accuracy, running time, scalability, etc. This survey aims to evaluate all major classes of graph embedding methods by considering algorithmic variations, parameter selections, scalability, hardware and software platforms, downstream ML tasks, and diverse datasets. We organized graph embedding techniques using a taxonomy that includes methods from manual feature engineering, matrix factorization, shallow neural networks, and deep graph convolutional networks. We evaluated these classes of algorithms for node classification, link prediction, clustering, and visualization tasks using widely used benchmark graphs. We designed our experiments on top of PyTorch Geometric and DGL libraries and run experiments on different multicore CPU and GPU platforms. We rigorously scrutinize the performance of embedding methods under various performance metrics and summarize the results. Thus, this paper may serve as a comparative guide to help users select methods that are most suitable for their tasks.